One of the not-too-subtle contradictions of “progressive” Muslim activism:

A common argument progressive Muslim activists and academics would often invoke against gender separation in Islamic Law is that it induced homosexuality. By keeping young men and women separate, Muslim society and culture was creating an environment conducive to homosexual desire and behavior. Therefore, gender separation should be abolished.

Nowadays, of course, such an argument would be seen as homophobic and contrary to the “correct” understanding of sexual orientation. You cannot “induce” homosexuality, and same-sex desire is not a product of environment, we are told. So this argument against gender separation has conveniently fallen out of favor with progressives.

NB: As I have written elsewhere, there is no conclusive evidence, Islamic or otherwise, to establish whether desire for the same sex is a product of nature or nurture. The fact that people with these desires do not choose to have them has no bearing on this question.


One of the not-too-subtle contradictions of "progressive" Muslim activism:A common argument progressive Muslim…

Posted by Daniel Haqiqatjou on Friday, September 16, 2016

Daniel Haqiqatjou

View all posts

Add comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *