Is Javed Ghamidi a Secret Qādiyānī?

The scholars who understand the methodology of Ghamidi recognize the issues and topics which he tries to cast doubt upon.

It is interesting to note that with regard to the belief of the finality of Nubuwwah (Prophethood), Ghamidi claims to have faith in it, but he curiously adopts a very soft stance on Mirza Ghulam Aḥmad Qādiyānī.

Ghamidi tries to present Qādiyānī as a ‘pious man.’[1] Ghamidi also says that if anyone claims to be a Muslim (which Qādiyānī does), then he (Ghamidi) has no right to state otherwise.[2] This is despite the fact that there is a scholarly consensus regarding the Qādiyānīs being disbelievers—in fact they have been declared disbelievers by thousands upon thousands of ‘Ulamā’. Moreover, they have even been declared to be a non-Muslim minority by court order in Pakistan.

Hereunder we shall present some of the stances of Javed Ghamidi on a number of pertinent issues—stances which closely resemble those of Mirza Ghulam Aḥmad Qādiyānī, the lying dajjāl (imposter).

RELATED: Javed Ghamidi: An Introduction to a Prominent Hadīth Denier

Denial of the Life of Sayyidunā ‘Isā ‘alayhi as-salām

Qādiyānī:

‘The grave of Sayyidunā ‘Isā ‘alayhi as-salām is in Jerusalem. It is present there to this day.’[3]

Ghamidi:

‘Whatever I have understood regarding Sayyidunā Masīḥ ‘alayhi as-salām from the Noble Qur’ān, it is that his soul was taken and immediately thereafter, his blessed body was raised, so that the Jews do not desecrate it.’[4]

RELATED: How Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Promoted Himself to Prophethood

Denial of the Descent of Sayyidunā ‘Isā ‘alayhi as-salām

Qādiyānī:

‘Besides myself, there is no place for any Masīḥ to set foot in the world after my time.’[5]

Ghamidi:

‘Although the Muḥaddithīn have generally accepted the reports on the descent of Masīḥ, but look in the light of the Noble Qur’ān, these reports seem problematic. Despite being of a problematic nature, there is no indication of this occurrence anywhere in the Noble Qur’ān. Can knowledge and the intellect be satisfied and content with this? It is not east to accept it.’[6]

RELATED: Misguided Ideology: Javed Ghamidi’s Rejection of Ḥadīth, the Mahdī and Ijmā’

Denial of the Mahdī

Qādiyānī:

‘I also say regarding the promised Mahdī that whatever Aḥādīth there are, all of them are defective and not a single one is authentic.’[7]

Ghamidi:

‘There is no need to wait for any promised Mahdī.’[8]

RELATED: The Mahdi in Sunnī Belief

May Allāh Ta’ālā protect the Muslim Ummah from every imposter and liar. Āmīn.

Notes

  1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WwVhjhrMOjw
  2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K-e9v7gy4kE
  3. Rūḥānī Khazā’in vol.8 p.299
  4. Ishrāq, p.45, April 1995
  5. Rūḥānī Khazā’in vol.16 p.243
  6. Mīzān p.178
  7. Rūḥānī Khazā’in vol.21 p.356
  8. Mīzān p.178

Follow Mufti Abdullah on Twitter: @MuftiAMoolla

MuslimSkeptic Needs Your Support!
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

4 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Ahmad

Abu ‘Lies’ “Maliki” of the UK holds similar positions, also the quack Imran Hossein.

akh

“…if anyone claims to be a Muslim (…), then he (…) has no right to state otherwise.”

Someone saying this most likely has bad intentions. This is also the manhaj of the insane left running the West right now. People can simply claim something without a clear definition based on firm principles. The goal is to confuse and demoralize people. To murky the waters. Once this happens people leave the religion because without clear definitions a religion doesn’t have practical application.

samir

i don’t think so.
it’s usual from these secularists and Sunnah rejectors to borrow doubts from all the enemies of Islam

The Commenter

He definitely has many deviant views, but it’s very irresponsive to say that he could be a secret Qadiani, we can neither judge someone’s heart, nor do we have any proof for that.
Those views that are listed in this article actually go against the Qadiani creed, because Qadianis don’t deny the arrival of Mahdi/Massih, while Ghamidi does.
Qadianis regard their false liar prophet Mirza Ghulam Ahmed Qadiani as their Mahdi/Massih.
Ghamidi also strictly opposes Sufism that the Qadianis support.