Türkiye’s New Intelligence Chief and His Critique of Modern Western Rationalism

    Date:

    Share post:

    The communications office of Türkiye’s recently re-elected President, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, has announced the appointment of a new head of the country’s National Intelligence Agency (MIT).

    Reuters reports:

    Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan appointed his spokesperson Ibrahim Kalin as the head of the National Intelligence Agency (MIT) on Monday, Erdogan’s communications office said.

    Hakan Fidan, who had been Turkey’s intelligence chief since 2010, was appointed foreign minister on Saturday.

    Kalin is a long-term confidant of Erdogan and has served as the spokesperson for the presidency and been a foreign policy adviser for the president since 2014.

    Kalin holds a Ph.D. from George Washington University on Islamic studies and was one of the founders of SETA, a pro-government think tank based in Ankara.

    Kalin has taken the lead on several diplomatic efforts in recent years, shaping Turkey’s foreign policy agenda.

    RELATED: Is Türkiye Becoming More Religious Under Erdogan’s Rule? Yes, It Is!

    Interestingly, as noted above, Kalin is actually also an academic specialized in Islamic metaphysics. He completed his PhD in Islamic Studies in 2003 at George Washington University, under the supervision of Seyyed Hossein Nasr; with his dissertation being about the epistemology of Mulla Sadra.

    This fact alone, of course, could be serious cause for concern. Nasr is infamous for being one of the main figures and proponents of Perennialism in the West, while Mulla Sadra (Sadr al-Din Shirazi) was a Shi’ah metaphysician from 17th century Safavid Iran who wanted to synthesize different trends of thoughts that can be deemed heretical in normative or traditional Sunni Islam.

    RELATED: The Jordan Peterson and Hamza Yusuf Discussion: A Review

    Now don’t get me wrong. We’re not, in any way, trying to condemn Kalin on such speculative grounds. Merely having Nasr as one’s thesis supervisor and writing on Mulla Sadra’s theory of knowledge as the focus of one’s dissertation doesn’t necessarily mean that you subscribe to their views, neither in part nor in totality.

    What we can do, though, is judge his own thoughts—particularly through a publication he penned a few years ago: Reason and Rationality in the Qur’an. (It has been referred to as an “essay” and a “research paper” but it is more like a brief booklet.)

    More precisely, we’ll take a look at what he has to say regarding modern Western philosophy and its emphasis on “reason alone.”

    Capitalism and Modern Irrationality

    As a mark of modernity, reason has been constructed as a self-regulating principle and the arbiter of truth from the mathematical and physical sciences to social and political orders. One modern tribute to it reads as follows: “The virtue of Rationality means the recognition and acceptance of reason as one’s only source of knowledge, one’s only judge of values and one’s only guide to action.” [Ayn Rand] But in reality, this rarefied view of reason, so passionately defended by academic philosophers, positivists, and the self-proclaimed Enlightenment rationalists, has never worked as expected. Nor has it delivered what it promised, namely, free individuals, rational society, universal equality, scientific culture, reason-bound politics, or economic justice. This in itself calls for a deep reflection about the reasonableness of the Enlightenment project of pure reason. At any rate, elements of “anti-reason” seem to have crept into the new world order promised by the Enlightenment, and the modern capitalist society with its evasive impersonalism, crude individualism, and structural violence is a far cry from a rational social order. (p.18)

    Rationalism as a Tool of Social Control

    Ever since the triumph of scientism in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century, reason as logic and rational inquiry has been hailed as a trait of modernity not because we want to grasp the reality of things in the Greek sense of the term but because a purely rational order is believed to enable us to have full control over the world. The instrumental rationality that defines our value schemes, educational systems, political orders, and daily lives provides handy justification for control, predictability, and dominion and gives a largely false sense of security, satisfaction, and fulfillment. It asserts that things are important because they have a use-value for us. The “rational” is the “useful”. Things no longer have intrinsic intelligibility or “rationality”; they have only use-value, which we are free to use in any way we want. (p.19)

    Modernism and Cold Rationality

    Reason in the modern period has oscillated between the two extremes of logical positivism and radical historicism. The former view, represented by the Vienna Circle and its followers, has construed reason as an absolute and timeless principle unaffected by history, custom, or such human frailties as emotion and desire. Rationality simply means proving that our concepts correspond to facts. It means drawing conclusions that fit the facts at hand. In this sense, rationality is essentially “logical consistency” and finds its purest expression in formal logic and scientific method. No other criteria count as a basis for rationality, and the value of everything from religion to art and education must be judged according to the logical and scientific dictates of this a-historic reason. Thus the values by which we are to live must be derived from the facts of nature that we must investigate through rational inquiry and logical analysis. All else is to be rejected as metaphysical nonsense. Reduced to a function of reasoning as formal logic, existence, too, is reduced to a logical term with no meaning and force outside logical-linguistic constructions. (p.19)

    RELATED: Rationality is Not the Whole Truth

    Postmodernism and Beyond Rationalism

    The second view, represented by the waves of postmodernism and constructivism since the 1960s, deconstructed reason to the point of turning it into a by-product of social-historical processes. Like all other human traits and enterprises, reason is a historically constructed notion whose meaning and function varies from one social setting to another. Rationality means applying the human capacity for thinking to different problem-solving situations. It has meaning only in the context of specific issues, problems, or research questions. Depending on the different types of human needs, rationality takes on new meanings and new functions. The defenders of this bounded view of reason insist that this is not to belittle the significance of reason or propose an irrational way of doing things. Rather, it is to admit the limitations of human reason. In this sense, rationality does not necessarily mean drawing conclusions that fit the facts. There are cases where the “anything goes” principle is more useful and functional than some abstract and mathematical notion of reason. (p.19)

    As demonstrated in the above excerpts, Kalin has clearly mastered the subject of Western philosophy. This is attested to not only by his footnotes referencing major Western thinkers, such as Heidegger and Feyerabend; but also through his ability to succinctly summarize complex ideas.

    Later on, in his work, he goes on to try and demonstrate how Islam both allows and encourages the use of reason as a tool. However, he makes it clear that this is within a hierarchy where supra-rational revealed and sacred knowledge remains superior—with reason most certainly not being the only access to truth as we see in Western modernity.

    Anyway, it’ll certainly be fascinating to see how all of this theoretical knowledge is applied and incorporated into his new role.

    RELATED: Islam vs. Modern Scientism: Is the Heart Merely an Organ?

    spot_img
    Bheria
    Bheria
    Researcher and writer focusing on comparative religion and philosophy

    12 COMMENTS

        • Then why don’t you guys also make articles on other topics like how the Europeans abolished slavery because they wanted to show they were civilized or on how the Nazis were hardcore Christians or on topics like ayacusa, or on the deobandis, or debunking hindutva and Hindu British myths or showing how the Christian empires and kingdoms were the true embodiment of Christianity and debunking the myth of a “peaceful Christianity” same thing with Buddhism. Or how all pre Islamic societies had theveil

          • Nazi’s weren’t Christian’s the only real “Christians” left are the Orthodox Church (of course going off of what we perceive as Christian today)

    1. I’m gonna be honest I didn’t understood anything but I know that the human mind is limited and science really doesn’t acknowledges it enough.
      For example, even assuming big bang/western cosmology (which I don’t adhere to), where is the border of the universe ? is the universe infinite ? if no then in what medium is the universe supposedly expanding ?
      Either your brain will melt from this or you’ll accept the scientist cop out of saying there’s nothing outside the universe but it’s expanding.

      • Nothing can ever be infinite except Allah. Big Bang/Western cosmology says universe is expanding, not infinite.It can be believed to the extent which it doesn’t contradict with Islam, because it’s grounded in the current understanding of the scientists and is derived through observations. Still, don’t even teach it to your kids and don’t try to learn any bit of it because there are falsehoods all over it, according to Qur’an and Sunnah. For example the age of universe being 15 billion years etc.

    LEAVE A REPLY

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here

    Newsletter

    If MuslimSkeptic gets banned from ALL social media, we'll need your email to stay in touch. Sign up NOW!

    Next Steps: Sync an Email Add-On

    To get the most out of your form, we suggest that you sync this form with an email add-on. To learn more about your email add-on options, visit the following page (https://www.gravityforms.com/the-8-best-email-plugins-for-wordpress-in-2020/). Important: Delete this tip before you publish the form.
    Name(Required)

    spot_img

    Popular

    More like this
    Related

    Was Mass Literacy a Mistake…?

    Readers coming across a title like that of this...

    The Evolution of Wahhabism into Secular Degeneracy

    Since its emergence in the mid-18th century the Wahhabi...

    End of US Military Aid to Israel: Victory or Strategic Reconfiguration?

    On November 3, 2026, Donald Trump announced that the...