The Rising Appeal of Anime with Muslims: Should We Be Concerned?

    Date:

    Share post:

    When engaging in spirited debate on Twitter, one tends to encounter a certain archetype of individuals that demand our attention. In times past, such individuals would have been ignored and quickly dismissed as inconsequential. Moreover, they would have felt so ashamed of themselves that they would simply remain invisible. Yes, I am referring to those Muslims who fervently go around debating Islam on Twitter while sporting a manga profile picture.

    This strange affinity between Muslims and manga is unfortunately becoming a growing trend. Although there are no specific figures available to accurately ascertain the scope of its prevalence within the Muslim community, it is undeniable that this phenomenon exists.

    Now, should we be worried?

    Speaking candidly, I myself previously had a fondness for manga and anime. However, considering the extremely unhealthy mixture of shirk, degeneracy, immorality, nudity, music, liberal propaganda/social engineering, and haram content that permeates anime, it is reasonable to assert that this form of entertainment should, at the very least, be avoided by Muslims.

    RELATED: The Occult in Anime: The Case of Evangelion

    My aim here, in this article, is not to embark on an extensive critique regarding the perils of manga but, rather, to conduct an examination.

    What exactly is it about manga that captivates the hearts of Muslim youth?

    Whatever the underlying reasons behind Muslims indulging in consuming manga, it is apparent that this medium occupies a significant place in the lives, hearts, and minds of its consumers. So, what are the factors that contribute to its resounding success?

    One obvious hypothesis suggests that manga offers respite from the daunting monotony of the modern daily existence, succinctly encapsulated by the “metro, work, sleep” routine dictated by capitalism. This monotonous reality has birthed a burgeoning hunger for compelling and exhilarating stories; and an escape from the mundane. And what simpler escape is there than through a medium that is entirely illustrated, capable of depicting the most fantastical scenarios?

    RELATED: Cyberpunk: The Secular Search for a Soul

    Yet, this explanation appears too facile, as it fails to account for why manga overshadows other franchises, such as American comics. Take, for instance, the astounding success of One Piece, which is well on its way to becoming the most profitable franchise of all time, currently second only to Superman, despite the latter’s much lengthier tenure.

    The overwhelming popularity of the Demon Slayer films and One Piece Red eclipses that of the Marvel films. Of course, this triumph may not be quantifiable in terms of cinema admissions alone, but it undoubtedly manifests itself as an all-consuming frenzy.

    So, what other explanations are there that might explain the underpinnings of this success?

    One could argue that the values instilled in the most beloved genre of manga, the shonen genre, resonate deeply with young readers. The motivation driving characters like Tanjiro to save his sister and slay Muzan; or the unwavering determination of Luffy to uncover One Piece and ascend the throne of pirates, inspires admiration in young minds. They find solace in the resilience of individuals like Thorfin, who never give up and persist in their fight, despite the significant hardships they have endured.

    These fictional figures fill a widening void of role models in our contemporary society, where infrastructure, security, and guaranteed healthcare stifle the opportunities to exhibit courage.

    Another explanation lies in the ability of manga to be able to satiate a craving for conflict and violence, a desire also evident in other domains such as video games. The awe-inspiring displays of strength by characters like Saitama; or the captivating clashes involving figures like Levi, provide stimulation. Stimulation of this kind becomes more and more significant as men find themselves increasingly reduced to passivity and subservience.

    Perhaps it is the convergence of all these factors that draws many of the Muslim youth towards manga and anime.

    In any case, understanding this phenomenon and seeking solutions is of paramount importance. It is having a detrimental impact on our younger generations, who are being shaped and moulded by manga and anime. We need to guide our young minds away from such things and, instead, direct them towards more enriching and beneficial alternatives that are not harmful to their faith.

    RELATED: Expose Your Children to Good and Wholesome Things

    spot_img
    Hud Lesprit
    Hud Lesprit
    Da`ee and hafiz of the Quran, focusing on atheism and secularism

    24 COMMENTS

    1. Another argument that can be made is that anime is also represents the how humans wants to look a perfect human skin and looks with no pimples and big eyes with no flaws on their skin and other stuff.

    2. Back in the past, i always wondered why the Muslim youth on the internet are keen on banning/making music haram but are watching anime as well? Considering how the latter theoretically brings more harm than music while also contain music in and of itself. Anime has music in intro, outro, battle scene and death scene. How can no one have strongly advocate banning these? Not to mention how it can have an affect of attachment to the character or the world inside that anime itself.

      • Please note that, i advocate banning music on the idea that it does distract me in a way that it makes me forget reality and transform your mind like alcohol but i never understand how there isn’t in a Muslim community that strongly advocate banning anime in a similar manner of they distracting people from reality and many other harm that it gives

        • Did i also mention how anime makes people fanboying and fangirling over a character that doesn’t even exist? And how they also committed bad crimes and anime tried to justify it by making them like some sort of vigilante?

          Shouldn’t we be teaching the youth’s about our hero via seerah of prophet Muhammad pbuh and his companion?

        • Let’s also not forget women are heavily sexualized and objectified in anime but you don’t hear a peep from the feminists and women’s rights activists.

        • When we were younger, we were told that music is haram but it is okay to watch anime is they are just cartoons. So we just need to cut the sound of videos when music is being played, especially since conversations are written (subbed videos). That is how I was seeing things.
          Anyway, Satan will lead people astray this way and may later find on problem in listening to music anime.
          Al-Hamdo Lillah, I no longer watch anime or even read manga …

    3. I’ve probably spend hundreds of hours watching and reading this degeneracy when I could have been reading about Islam and the Prophet SAW. Definitely one reason why I liked this stuff is because of the characters having their epic moment beating the bad guy and overcoming their hardships. But is there any actual value in this medium? It’s all fiction and came from the minds of Kaffir. I and every other Muslim should read about actual Muslims who struggled but overcome their hardships for Allah.

      • I still watch and read those stuff and yet my iman remain resolute. If you think anime will lead everyone astray, you clearly have a problem, both mentally and spiritually. But alas, you did a good choice on staying away on anime, cause I can testify it’s becoming more and more risque. Nevertheless, I still watch and read anime & manga because I’m looking for a good story, not as some sort of escapist material

    4. Another reason why anime is popular is because anime is about teenagers who are under the age of 18 having the freedom to act like an adult. Some anime shows have story lines where teenagers get married, teenagers join the military and etc. There’s even some anime shows with the story line of a teenage girl marrying or falling in love with a man that’s 10 to 20 years older then her. It’s the fantasy of teenagers wanting to be treated like a mature adult and not having to wait until they are 18.

        • Correct but due to capitalism and educational system transforming in a way that you’re a kid until you’re 18 and you don’t have the responsibilities like people had in the past. For example my grandfather was running a business at 15 and when i was 15 i barely could take care of my ownself while he was taking care of a family.

          I think it harms to not be given responsibilities.

    5. Also the inevitable viewing of, and addiction to pornography, and thereafter lgbtqiaTreeToaster and liberal, secular Ideology. Allah swt save us and our progeny ameen.

    6. JazaakAllahu khairan

      I have consumed a lot of anime and do so as an alternative to watching insta, tiktok, porn or netflix all of which can quickly lead to seeking Zina.

      I see the filthy depictions of shirk and nudity and agree that its not a wholesome alternative at all.

      It is addictive and time consuming and I pray that one day I will spend my time wisely and properly.

      I wholeheartedly agree with your article.

      BarakAllahu feek.

    7. If you notice in anime, every evil character = darker skin, every good character = lighter skin.
      Supposedly that’s Japanese culture of evil = darker and that’s not correlated to race. Japanese culture is not ideal, birth rate so low it’s getting scary for them, they fetishize western body type which leads to body dysmorphia, promote girly mannerism in men, and like the West despite 2 nuclear bombs.
      It’s actually sad to see how the USA dominated them that bad.
      Samurais would be ashamed.

    8. For me what I found compelling about anime was that I could experience stories that made me feel powerful and that had a tendency to be very philosophical or abstract.

    9. Anime also does a great job of showcasing powerful family bonds or friendship bonds. It’s possible that people are lonely and are finding solace in these, wishing that they could also have such bonds.

    10. A very decent description indeed, Muslim youth that aren’t well versed with the islamic paradigm and lack islamic knowledge ,and etiquettes that anime abuses like awrah and females are pretty susceptible to secular ideologies at some point it even affects their gheirah and morality when they aren’t able to evade what they are supposed to be sensitive towards.

    11. at least for arabs, it was dubbed in Arabic fus-ha and it was adopted to the mainstream many decades ago, as in people in their 60 and 70 know anime shows but the names are different, for example, an anime went by the name of “adnan wa leana” obviously those names aren’t japanese. another one is “captain majid” which is actually captain tsubasu in Japanese. the themes were manipulated and things were sometimes edited a bit to fit an Arabian audiance also their cloths someties looked middle easte

    12. Another concerning topic is that majority of these mangas and animes are normalising concepts like black magic rituals, contact with the unseen world (jinns), making deals with the devil and satanic philosophy in general in a subtle way. Mangas and animes like black clover, chainsaw man, hell’s paradise, how not to summon a demon, jujutsu kaisen, Seven Deadly Sins, Naruto and many more.
      The point is the there is a common theme that most of the leading manga’s and anime’s share that is linked.

    LEAVE A REPLY

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here

    Newsletter

    If MuslimSkeptic gets banned from ALL social media, we'll need your email to stay in touch. Sign up NOW!

    Next Steps: Sync an Email Add-On

    To get the most out of your form, we suggest that you sync this form with an email add-on. To learn more about your email add-on options, visit the following page (https://www.gravityforms.com/the-8-best-email-plugins-for-wordpress-in-2020/). Important: Delete this tip before you publish the form.
    Name(Required)

    spot_img

    Popular

    More like this
    Related

    A Critique of the Shi’ah Imamate Doctrine

    Our dear brother Daniel Haqiqatjou recently participated in a...

    Manufacturing the Liberal Man: An Epigenetic Theory of Modernity

    A few years ago, I had written an article...

    Kadyrovism: New Paradigm for Islam in Secular States?

    For a certain generation of Muslims, particularly Millennials and...