Reason: Bridging the Gap Between Heart and Brain

    Date:

    Share post:

    In the ongoing discourse between scientism, modernism, and the teachings of Islam, a significant contention arises regarding the center of reason. While some claim that reason is something that resides solely in the brain, adherents of Islam argue that the heart also holds a vital role in this domain.

    In this article, we shall delve a little further into this intriguing topic, shedding light on the metaphysical underpinnings of this debate, while providing scientific evidence that challenges the prevailing narrative.

    I shall also aim to debunk, using some concise points, the allegation that the Qur’an supposedly makes a mistake in attributing to the heart the ability to reason.

    1. The prevailing belief that the brain houses the center of our consciousness stems from the natural assumption that we reside in our heads. This perception is primarily influenced by the placement of our eyes, which are situated in our cranium. However, if, for example, our eyes were located upon our chest, we would likely have theorized that our consciousness resides in that region. It is crucial to recognize that this interpretation rests on mere subjective perceptions rather than any actual concrete scientific evidence.

    2. Within the Islamic tradition, the question of the center of reason is not devoid of controversy. As explained by notable scholars like Ibn Taymiyyah, the Arabic term for heart, “qalb,” can also refer to the internal sphere of the body. Such an interpretation naturally challenges the assumption that reason is confined solely to the brain and acknowledges the possibility of an alternative perspective.

    وقد يراد بالقلب باطن الإنسان مطلقا فإن قلب الشيء باطنه كقلب الحنطة واللوزة والجوزة ونحو ذلك ومنه سمي القليب قليبا لأنه أخرج قلبه وهو باطنه وعلى هذا فإذا أريد بالقلب هذا فالعقل متعلق بدماغه أيضا ولهذا قيل : إن العقل في الدماغ . كما يقوله كثير من الأطباء ونقل ذلك عن الإمام أحمد ويقول طائفة من أصحابه : إن أصل العقل في القلب فإذا كمل انتهى إلى الدماغ

     

    “Sometimes, the inside of a human being in general (and not specifically the organ of the “heart”) is meant by “qalb”; because the “qalb” of something is its inside, like the qalb of a wheat grain, almond, walnut etc. Hence a well/ditch is called “qaleeb” because its inside (qalb) has been taken out. On this basis, if this is what is meant by “qalb”, the intellect is connected to the brain also (as the brain is included in the “inside” of a human being). Hence it has been said the intellect is located in the brain, as stated by many physicians. This has been narrated from Imam Ahmad. A group of his companions said that the intellect originates in the heart, then when it reaches perfection it ends up in the brain.” (Ibn Taymiyyah. Majmu’ al-Fatawa, 9/303)

    The point Ibn Taymiyyah is making here is that, if you take this more general meaning of “qalb,” then the brain is also included therein.

    RELATED: Islam vs. Modern Scientism: Is the Heart Merely an Organ?

    3. In a departure from conventional beliefs pertaining to rationality, modern research presents a thought-provoking perspective that recognizes the inherent irrationality of human beings. This perspective does not undermine the teachings of Islam but the very naturalistic idea of a center of reason. Antonio Damasio’s influential work, The Mistake of Descartes, shows that people are actually very irrational.

    There is clearly a major inconsistency in criticizing Islam based on a purported lack of a singular center of reason when scientific evidence supports the inherent irrationality of human beings.

    RELATED: The Innate Fitra in the Heart of Every Newborn Child!

    4. To further dispel the notion that reason resides exclusively within the brain, scientific research has shed light on the heart’s remarkable capabilities. Recent findings indicate that the heart possesses its own “intrinsic cardiac nervous system” composed of approximately 40,000 neurons, which is comparable to what is found in the brain. This revelation signifies the existence of a neural network within the heart, indicating that it plays a significant role beyond its conventional function as a pump.

    From the abstract of a scientific review published on Pubmed:

    Recent findings: Dr. Armour, in 1991, discovered that the heart has its “little brain” or “intrinsic cardiac nervous system.” This “heart brain” is composed of approximately 40,000 neurons that are alike neurons in the brain, meaning that the heart has its own nervous system. In addition, the heart communicates with the brain in many methods: neurologically, biochemically, biophysically, and energetically. The vagus nerve, which is 80% afferent, carries information from the heart and other internal organs to the brain. Signals from the “heart brain” redirect to the medulla, hypothalamus, thalamus, and amygdala and the cerebral cortex. Thus, the heart sends more signals to the brain than vice versa. Research has demonstrated that pain perception is modulated by neural pathways and methods targeting the heart such as vagus nerve stimulation and heart-rhythm coherence feedback techniques. The heart is not just a pump. It has its neural network or “little brain.”

    5. The prevailing naturalistic worldview tends to dismiss the existence of a center of reason altogether. However, this perspective leads to an absurd conclusion, denying the fundamental nature of human consciousness. By acknowledging the heart’s intricate neural network and its profound impact on cognitive processes, we challenge the reductionist claims of scientism and modernism, offering an alternative paradigm that incorporates the wisdom of the Qur’an.

    In conclusion, the understanding that reason resides solely within the brain is not a definitive fact but rather a metaphysical claim. Islam, with its profound intellectual tradition and guidance from the Qur’an, recognizes the potential role of the heart in cognition.

    Modern scientific research has indeed shed light on the heart’s remarkable neural network and its intricate system of communication with the brain. These findings challenge the limited perspective that confines reason exclusively to the brain, underscoring the profound significance of the heart in shaping our thoughts and emotions.

    In this context, it is essential to acknowledge the unparalleled wisdom and guidance provided by the Shari’ah and the Qur’an.

    So have they not journeyed through the lands to have hearts to understand with and ears they truly hear with? For it is not the eyes that become blind but the hearts within the breasts that go blind. (Qur’an, 24:46)

    RELATED: Islam and Mental Health: The Real Solution to the Depression Epidemic

    spot_img
    Hud Lesprit
    Hud Lesprit
    Da`ee and hafiz of the Quran, focusing on atheism and secularism

    10 COMMENTS

    1. What happens though if the heart conflicts with the brain? Could a Christian argue he is reasonable becoming he “feels” in his heart that God is three? (astagfirullah)

      • What heart conflicting the brain means?

        We aren’t saying that people should follow emotions because heart is the center of reason…

    2. No, sorry as a neuroscience student this is just wrong. The human brain on average consists or approximately 86 BILLION neurons, which is a about two million one hundred fifty thousand times more than the 40,000 in the heart. There are less neurons in the heart than in the brains of incredibly simple organisms like lobsters or fish and even some insects. There has never been any convincing scientific evidence that any thought processes happen in the heart. This isn’t to disparage your religion.

      • With all due respect, you are just showing how even neuroscience student have a very weak understanding of the philosophy of the mind.

        Even if they were 0 neurons in the heart it wouldn’t prove that the heart isn’t the center of reason.

        Reason or consciousness aren’t empirical matters. Neurons are neurons, not consciousness.

    3. Makes sense. The way I always thought about is that the heart is like the King (making bigger picture decisions that guide the trajectory) and the brain is like the Vizier (executing small task that follow the trajectory).

      Also I think it was Hume who said “Reason is the slave of the passions.” So the brain essentially processes information based on the criteria that sits in the heart. Similarly, this shows how people will justify things through reasoning conforming to beliefs or “passions.”

    4. جَزَاكَ ٱللَّٰهُ. Al Qur’an and Shari’ah should be the yardstick and not science. As a matter of fact, science is a true قلب, as it always changes.

    LEAVE A REPLY

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here

    Newsletter

    If MuslimSkeptic gets banned from ALL social media, we'll need your email to stay in touch. Sign up NOW!

    Next Steps: Sync an Email Add-On

    To get the most out of your form, we suggest that you sync this form with an email add-on. To learn more about your email add-on options, visit the following page (https://www.gravityforms.com/the-8-best-email-plugins-for-wordpress-in-2020/). Important: Delete this tip before you publish the form.
    Name(Required)

    spot_img

    Popular

    More like this
    Related

    Was Mass Literacy a Mistake…?

    Readers coming across a title like that of this...

    The Evolution of Wahhabism into Secular Degeneracy

    Since its emergence in the mid-18th century the Wahhabi...

    A Critique of the Shi’ah Imamate Doctrine

    Our dear brother Daniel Haqiqatjou recently participated in a...