Viral Video: Brother Beats Sister for Her Online Dancing

    Date:

    Share post:

    News has spread of a “honor” beating.

    WARNING: DISTURBING

    You will immediately notice that this so-called act of “honor revenge” is clearly not condoned within Islam. In fact, it would most certainly be haram (unlawful):

    • In Islam, it is explicitly forbidden for someone to strike a person on the face.
    • In Islam, the brother has no right to hit his sister for something she’s done.
    • Even in those cases where Islam permits ta’zir (physically disciplining someone) for things like reformation and educational purposes, it is not permissible to resort to such radically violent measures.

    RELATED: Comparing “Wife Beating” in Judaism, Christianity, Hinduism, Buddhism, and Islam

    Predictably, Islamophobes seized this as a golden opportunity for them to unjustly attack Islam, without even making the slightest attempt to hide their malicious intent.

    This is obviously an idiotic attempt to undermine Islam, to say the very least. You simply cannot criticize a religion based on the actions of some of its adherents, when that very same religion deems those actions to be unlawful. Yet, these same individuals fail to acknowledge the significant rates of violence against women within Western countries, despite the prevalent rise of atheism and liberalism in those countries.

    Women in the West frequently experience abuse at the hands of jealous family members or partners. Then there’s the undeniable fact that a very significant percentage of abuse is linked to alcohol consumption, something that is expressly forbidden in Islam.

    Alcohol plays an important part in IPV. The study found that 30 to 40 percent of the men and 27 to 34 percent of the women who perpetrated violence against their partners were drinking at the time of the event. Alcohol-related problems were associated with IPV among blacks and whites, but not among Hispanics. Alcohol’s role in partner violence may be explained by people’s expectations that alcohol will have a disinhibitory effect on behavior or by alcohol’s direct physiological disinhibitory effect. It is also possible that people consciously use alcohol as an excuse for their violent behavior or that alcohol appears to be associated with violence because both heavier drinking and violence have common predictors, such as an impulsive personality.

    In fact, there are no studies to date that indicate that violence against women is more prevalent among Muslims.

    What would these haters think, for example, if someone were to use examples such as the above to try and push the idea that atheists are inherently violent people who love to just go around beating their women for no reason at all?

    They would probably laugh at the moronic reasoning behind such a crazy claim—and rightly so. Yet, they ironically use this very same line of argument against Islam at every opportunity they get.

    RELATED: [WATCH] Is There “WIFE BEATING” in Islam? UNAPOLOGETIC Answer

    Dances with Dayyuth

    The reactions to this video also reveal some other underlying issues. Yes, the brother’s actions were obviously egregious and appalling. I’m sure nobody will object to that. However, none of the comments recognize the importance of ensuring the responsible behavior of women on social media. Instead, they all adhere to the same socially engineered flawed liberal notion of women being encouraged to express their “freedom” to do whatever they feel at any given moment, regardless of how it will affect them mentally, physically, and spiritually.

    This type of thinking has contributed significantly to the moral decay and corruption of Western society. These individuals are responsible for the rise of platforms such as OnlyFans and the proliferation of TikTok dance videos.

    This sweeping  corruption of women’s morality has led to decreased satisfaction in marriages, the breakdown of the family unit, and a mental health epidemic. The prevailing culture of exhibitionism, normalized by those who lack virtue, makes it extremely challenging for men to find women who are honorable and dignified.

    Allow me to, once again, reiterate my sincere condemnation of all that transpired, as it undeniably goes against the most basic teachings of Islam. However, this does not, in any way, mean that I think such actions by women should go completely unchecked. Her actions also go against the most basic teachings of Islam. Under Islamic law, both the qadi (judge) and her wali (guardian) or husband would have the right to punish her, within the limits of the shari’ah of course.

    Furthermore, a society in which degeneracy is met with the most severe and unjust consequences is still more preferable to one where degeneracy not only goes completely unchecked but is also encouraged.

    What modern reformists and Islamophobes fail to mention is that they secretly desire a world where such shameful and despicable displays are met with no repercussions whatsoever.

    As a community, we need to find a halal and intelligent approach to guide our sisters and steer them away from such a brainwashed mindset of immodesty and immorality.

    RELATED: An App Like No Other: The Social Cancer That Is TikTok

    Social media stands as one of the most detrimental catastrophes of modern society. It is a tool for social-engineering and it leads to severe mental health problems. It facilitates moral depravity and open sinning on unprecedented levels. Despite this, we are yet to find an effective solution to prevent it from corrupting our innocent and unsuspecting Muslim youth. Through social media, many brothers and sisters have become engaged in premarital relationships. Many have had their Islamic beliefs and morals engineered and warped in favor of liberalism. Many have fallen prey to immoral, sinful, and idiotic trends.

    I believe this sickness is one that must also be eradicated from the West too, for we cannot allow our communities to succumb to such a dangerous and misleading path.

    Do not be swayed by the backlash of these weak-willed and feeble-minded individuals. Some people are led astray by the diseases that reside in the depths of their hearts, while others uphold justice and understand that Islam does not endorse the actions of the brother or the sister.

    This replies exemplify that those who stray from the path of Islam are often malignant individuals with shallow thinking, and neither does Islam nor does the Muslim ummah require their presence. Iman (faith) is a blessing from Allah. He bestows it upon whomever He wills and he deprives whomever He wills from its light. Never take it for granted.

    If these despicable individuals were truly virtuous, they would have criticized the actions of both the brother and the sister. They would not justify the actions of either party.

    And if they had even an iota of intelligence or honesty, they would never conflate the actions of either of them with Islam when it forbids both.

    RELATED: Is Islamophobe Steven Crowder a Wife Beater? A Muslim Perspective

    spot_img
    Hud Lesprit
    Hud Lesprit
    Da`ee and hafiz of the Quran, focusing on atheism and secularism

    38 COMMENTS

      • im muslim, and this incident is fake as i highlighted in my other cooment, but if this was true this would be horrifying and he should be imprisoned for assault. it is clearly understood by most islamic scholars you cant even strike your wives for discipline harder than a shove with a short softish thing (toothbrush, pen, gluestick, miswak….) in islam it is even banned to tuch the face with harm.

    1. Interesting to see that the first thing she thought of doing after being beaten senseless is go to social media. It probably looks much more severe than it really is.

      I don’t condone this type of beating but do understand the anger and frustration of a brother whos sister is wayward and brings shame to the family. His gheerah is commendable, the way he dealt with it not so much.

      Rebellious women like this will only get wilder and more shameless the harsher you deal with them.

    2. That person in not a westerner who expressed his/her “concern” in the above tweet but a low iq, intellectually handicapped lindu. It is apparent from his pfp.

    3. Extreme times call for extreme measures. You can’t talk to these women anymore or sit them down and explain to them anything. Who knows how many times the brother advised her to stop. While yes striking the face is haram sometimes people lose control because of the amount of greriah the brother has and he just lost it. Men are being suppressed more and more everyday and told to just accept things and after years and years of build up sometimes you get this. May Allah SWT forgive us and guide us

      • While what the sister did was wrong, two wrongs don’t make a right, and the brother doesn’t deserve sympathy for his deplorable actions. We, as Muslims, should have more self control.

    4. there are many desi muslims who doing dancing with Bollywood songs yuk, why we muslims not condemn that, many hindus subscribe and enjoying only to the muslim women dance

    5. The twitter account who posted the video is run by an Islamophobic Hindu. Same people whose religion does barbaric practices like Sati, and whose country is considered the worst place for women, whose people praised r**ists like the one in the Kathua rape case, who released the 11 men convicted of r**ing Bilko Bano, and idolizes Modi and the Marathas, who caused crimes against women in Gujarat and Bengal.

      That Hindu dude is probably happy the muslim woman got beaten up like that.

      • If it’s posted by a hindu, it should be safely ignored. They are known to make fake and doctored videos. Their religion is in the sewer and the only way they can feel good about themselves is by posting fake videos on social media and claiming it is done by Muslims. All the while begging to Dubai Arabs to give them jobs!

      • What do you expect from people whose religion teaches that five brothers shared a wife?
        Women being sl*ts and men being c*cks are not problematic to them.

    6. The brother is a failure, not only did he overstep his bound in what he did to his sister, he didn’t do anything about her phone, she was still able to post videos. He didn’t use his brains, instead he only used his emotions, if he used brains, he would have taken away her phone and prevented her from being able to post videos online.

      Though this is if the sister is not lying about being beaten by her brother, or this isn’t some sort of psyops against muslims, who knows, this might be fake

      • that is a filter and makeup in the crying video, look at it closely and youll see it. my comment explains how it probably happened.

    7. Where’s the evidence that it is the same woman and that the beating is real, not just make-up effects? Is there a police report on the same story? If there was indeed a beating of the same person, was it a routine crime like burglary or mugging by random offenders, or an act of ‘honor revenge’ by a male relative?

      • That was exactly what I was thinking , I even noticed some differences between the facial and body structure of the two woman. Plus the woman proclaimed to be dancing in the first video seemed to be very confident with her acts , I don’t even know if she was dancing, that’s not an image of some rebellious lowlife with her brother waiting with the stick on the corner. This video can be a complete scam . And a cheap version of false propaganda .

        • the reason for the difference is her using a tiktok filter to deform her face for clout. look at my top comment for more info.

    8. When women behave in extreme ways (flaunting their beauty on the internet and contributing to the spread of depravity in society) then you cannot blame some men for taking “extreme” measures to check that behavior.

      Some people may see this girls beaten face and feel bad for her, but the damage she’s caused to so many countless people through her actions on social media is probably proportionately worse.

    9. my god guys, i looked at the crying video closely, you can carefully point the exact second the tiktok filter turned off accidentally, revealing her unscathed facial structure. she likely got merely scolded by her brother for the dancing video, got mad, messed up her hair, drew bruises on her face with make up, applied a face deforming filter then filmed a video fake crying just to shame her brother. people this is a scam. she never likely got even touched.

    10. its all fake, she has makeup and a filter on as you can carefully see in the crying video, in her later tiktoks her face is perfectly fine, and she even admitted nothing happened to her and that she was just a clout chaser (you can see on her page she is milking her injuries, and and yet they disappear completely in the very next video)

    11. You can’t strike someone on the face? That’s the dumbest thing I’ve ever heard 🤣 yeah when a guy is trying to mug me I’ll just gently massage his face 🤦‍♂️

      • Do you know the difference between Ta’zir punishments and self defense? Why are you conflating the two without knowledge

    12. If a Fasiq (liar- evil person) comes to you with any news, verify it, lest you should harm people in ignorance, and afterwards you become regretful for what you have done. Quran: 49: 6

    13. Women are driven emotionally to adopt liberal ideas by the dramas ,anime series that are dubbed into arabic.
      Yes it does bring some good things from other cultures to the arabs, but they re successful in creating an emotional bond with the lifestyle of the characters and their beliefs…

      We muslims are way behind becs as in the past animation for dawah purpose was considered haram becs drawing pictures is haram.
      Similarly we te stuck with the entertainment industry.

    14. One of the acts of violence against women in the West is pushing the use of C Sections on women who don’t need it. Is there a greater violence than cutting open the belly of a pregnant woman for the sake of money?

    LEAVE A REPLY

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here

    Newsletter

    If MuslimSkeptic gets banned from ALL social media, we'll need your email to stay in touch. Sign up NOW!

    This field is hidden when viewing the form

    Next Steps: Sync an Email Add-On

    To get the most out of your form, we suggest that you sync this form with an email add-on. To learn more about your email add-on options, visit the following page (https://www.gravityforms.com/the-8-best-email-plugins-for-wordpress-in-2020/). Important: Delete this tip before you publish the form.
    Name(Required)

    spot_img

    Popular

    More like this
    Related

    The Autonomous Self Cult: Ayah and the Inevitability of “Muslim Feminism”

    You may have come across some of the recent...

    Compassionate Imams Spreading False Compassion and Rewriting Morality

    Like many others, I still choose to not be...

    Early Muslim Encounters with Feminism: Women’s Education in the Late Ottoman Empire

    Feminist theory and the liberal ideological foundations it emerged...

    Exposing Jewish Israeli Organization IMPACT-SE’s Sinister Agenda to Deform Islam

    The Muslim ummah has recently been directing a well-deserved...