Is Islam Just “Arab Colonialism”? Debunking Lazy Anachronism

    Date:

    Share post:

    Since 7/10, you may have noticed that the Zionists have unleashed an endless stream of shills eager to repeat the old (and debunked) talking points that were in vogue after 9/11, including this idea that Islamic conquests embodied a certain form of “Arab colonialism.”

    Ironically, it’s as though they tacitly acknowledge that Israel is in fact a settler-colonial entity, by proudly declaring:

    “Look, Islam has been a settler-colonial project too.”

    On X (formerly Twitter), you’ll see many from various different backgrounds taking issue with the usage of such terminology.

    Of course, in the specific case of Islam, such a comparison is most certainly misplaced. This is because Islamic conquests are referred as fatḥ (pl. futūḥ). They are quite literally a form of “opening” or genuine liberation, freeing entire populations, cultures, and even civilizations from the evils of Shirk (polytheism) and introducing them to Tawḥīd (pure monotheism), from being the slaves of false deities to being servants of their Creator.

    They thus cannot be equated with the purely materialistic processes of territorial expansionism.

    Such an interpretation will be dismissed by those adopting a more secular approach as, for them, expanding in the name of Truth or expanding in the name of something materialistic is one and the same. This is due to the fact that they’re incapable of seeing how spiritual matters are more essential to the human existence.

    As such, I would like to present an insight from Malek Bennabi (1905–1973), a prominent Algerian thinker of Islam who remains relatively underrated in English-speaking communities.

    Bennabi has many good works, beginning with his very first published book, Le Phénomène Coranique (The Qur’anic Phenomenon). It was written in French and published in 1947. However, it remains quite relevant particularly because of the way he approaches the Qur’an—debunking Orientalist myths, including that of the Qur’an allegedly having “copied” the Bible, while showing the important differences in how the Qur’an narrates the story of Prophet Yusuf (peace be upon him) in comparison to the Bible, even demonstrating how the Biblical text contains obvious historical errors that the Qur’an does not commit.

    RELATED: Did the Qur’an Copy the Talmud… or Is It the Other Way Around?

    Bennabi was also what you could call a “civilizationist” thinker, that is, a writer who approaches history holistically, taking into account all the different sciences or fields (economics, anthropology, sociology, etc.), and you would struggle to find many such authors even in the Western tradition (among the rare few names that do exist, you have Oswald Spengler, Arnold Toynbee, and perhaps Christopher Dawson).

    Bennabi was thus armed to the teeth with theoretical knowledge, even in nominally secular fields. This allowed him to provide insights and interpretations that, on the onset, might appear trivial while ultimately being paradigm-defining.

    A contribution of this nature is the way he contrasts “colonialism” with “provincialism.” Simply put, the colonialist approach is purely modernist and, in terms of economics, it means that the metropolis (e.g., Paris) absorbs or steals the surplus labor and natural resources of the colonies (e.g., Algeria).

    It is also modernist because it involves typically modernist configurations, such as the highly centralized State, which has been encouraged by France since Philip IV of France as early as the 14th century (you may refer to our article regarding the genesis of French secularism for more details).

    Readers should now understand why the Islamic conquests simply cannot be described as Arab colonialism. For starters, there was no idea of centralized state or capitalist exploitation. Rather, there was a form of decentralization that Bennabi calls provincialism, in the sense that there were localized authorities co-existing within a Khilāfah system, with each possessing their own cultural and economic dynamics.

    For example, if it was truly colonialism, the Ḥijāz region would have hosted all the empires and dynasties and would have drained all the wealth from regions such as North Africa, Syria, etc. Instead, you would hard pressed to find any trace of “Arab colonialism” in today’s Saudi Arabia (think, for example, of monuments). This is because Islam wasn’t (Saudi) Arab imperialism. The conquerors had never established any powerful political authority there.

    Islamic civilization would also not have been as prolific, in terms of writers, etc., if there was centralization, compared to, say, how virtually all French “intellectuals” are from Paris. If that had been the case, due to the high level of centralization, in terms of politics, economics, and culture, the vast majority of traditional Muslim scholars would thus have been from the Ḥijāz.

    RELATED: Did French “Intellectuals” Become Extremists or Were They Always Extremists?

    Instead, we find that it is in fact the Khorasan region that has traditionally been overrepresented. Even within Khorasan itself, this sense of centralization did not exist, with all of them not hailing from one single “major” city, for instance, Bukhara. Rather, even cities that are now lost to history, such as Tus in modern-day Iran, have birthed countless prominent names, including the much-celebrated Imam Ghazālī (may Allah have mercy on him).

    RELATED: [Book Review] Rejecting Freedom and Progress: The Islamic Case Against Capitalism

    But, to put it as plainly as possible, Islamic conquests are not comparable to European colonialism because that would be anachronistic, and it would dismiss the complex history involved in institutions and practices typical of liberal modernity.

    We could also move beyond the initial Islamic conquests, and we could say that the supposed “imposition” of Arabic (and, in many contexts, even Arab culture) was also more natural than forced. The Arabic language was considered the language of culture and commerce, and the élite (thus the masses emulating them) had everything to gain in adopting it. This could be compared somewhat to how English was adopted by millions of Americans of German descent or how, in our era of neoliberal globalization, English has become an international language spoken by great numbers of people on all continents, without any form of coercion (of course, secularist activists will have no problem with the subtle imposition of a language, just as long as it is associated with liberal forms of socialization).

    Academics such as Shahab Ahmed have argued that what defined the post-classical Islamic civilization (following the Mongol attack on Baghdad in 1258) was not the Arabic language or Arab culture, rather the Persian language and Persian culture. The late Shahab Ahmed himself termed this phenomenon “the Balkans-to-Bengal complex,” since, from modern-day Bosnia to modern-day Bangladesh and everything in-between, authors were absorbing the works of Persian writers such as Rumi and Hafez and taking them as literary inspiration… quite the peculiar form of Arab colonialism, where Persian ultimately acquired such great and widespread prestige!

    It’s an entirely different debate, to the extent that Arab nationalist authors, in their typical historiography, have often lamented the fact that Islam has empowered non-Arabs: the Persians, to culturally dominate them during the Abbasid caliphate; and the Ottomans, to rule over them directly for centuries…

    So Islam essentially becomes such a strange and unique form of Arab colonialism that Arab nationalists (often Christians) find that, for centuries (roughly from the 13th to the 20th century), Arabs actually had no real political power at all!

    RELATED: Netanyahu’s Messianic Objective: Armageddon and Slavery of All Non-Jews?

    spot_img
    Bheria
    Bheria
    Researcher and writer focusing on comparative religion and philosophy

    39 COMMENTS

    1. I just had a very disturbing thought. Should Muslims stop supporting Hamas on Western social media platforms, because we are breaking the promise we made when.sugning up, to not support designated t*****ist groups, and thus sinning?

      • I’m not sure but read the Muslimskeptic disclaimer about Hamas,
        Editor’s Note: Due to Zionist lobbying, Hamas is considered a proscribed terrorist group in the US, UK, and several other nations. However, in 2018, the UN rejected a motion to condemn Hamas. The majority of nations consider Hamas to be the legitimate government of the Palestinians.
        Due to these legal restrictions in the West, at MuslimSkeptic, we are not allowed to support Hamas.

      • However, we are also under no legal obligation to condemn them. We are also legally allowed to investigate factual questions, such as whether or not Hamas committed terrorism on October 7th. We are also legally able to praise Palestinians in general, as well as to praise the Palestinian resistance to genocide and occupation in general terms. This right of Palestinians to militarily resist genocide is also licit according to international law.

      • I’m not sure but read the Muslimskeptic disclaimer about Hamas,
        Editor’s Note: Due to Zionist lobbying, Hamas is considered a proscribed terrorist group in the US, UK, and several other nations. However, in 2018, the UN rejected a motion to condemn Hamas. The majority of nations consider Hamas to be the legitimate government of the Palestinians.
        Due to these legal restrictions in the West, at MuslimSkeptic, we are not allowed to support Hamas.

      • However, we are also under no legal obligation to condemn them. We are also legally allowed to investigate factual questions, such as whether or not Hamas committed terrorism on October 7th. We are also legally able to praise Palestinians in general, as well as to praise the Palestinian resistance to genocide and occupation in general terms. This right of Palestinians to militarily resist genocide is also licit according to international law.
        maybe just post that?

          • I changed my initial comment after I looked it up and saw we were allowed deception in war (which we are at with the West, whether we want it or not) but not to break trusts even at war, so you are correct.
            But at this point we don’t have alternatives, so it’s a bit like eating pork on a desert island kind of a situation.

          • I know you rafidah lack adab,and akhlaaq but don’t show this here.There is a community rules and guidelines.Keep your sectarian hatred within yourself.

      • There is no obedience above the obedience of Allah, if they designate a terrorist group, but they follow quran and sunnah, then disbobey the kuffar

    2. The Islamic massacres of the Jews be like:
      In 1812, the Egyptian army conquered Khartoum, there they genocided 3 Jewish people …

    3. Zionists always assume that we’re all ardent ethno-nationalists like them. They don’t even make an effort now, it’s all about repeating the same old, tired, lazy tropes that we can swat aside with ease.

      Never mind that Arabs make up only 18% of the global Muslim population, or the literary and cultural significance of the Persians and Ottomans that the article mentioned, or even the might of the Mamluks, Seljuks from Central Asia, the Mughals, the Malay Archipelago etc.

    4. Awesome article I would like any books or refrences to refuted Neo con claims that Europe did not become rich from colonialism which is a joke 😂😆

      • And as the article pointed out there is not comparison between the Muslim conquests and European colonialism as the article rightfully pointed out all the wealth went back to European countries while Europeans Kia billions the Europeans Kia 100 million native Americans and 80-120 million Africans and 300 million-2 billion people of the subcontinent and stole their resources more specifically Britain steaming 45 trillion dollars from the subcontinent

        • And to make things worse the natives were treated like shet and the colonizers rarely intermarried with the natives and allowed them to rise the ranks and the natives were rarely integrated in these settler colonial societies.

      • As if the gold, copper, iron, zinc, minerals, wood, coal, oil, manpower comes from Europe ? They destroyed their forests, have little mineral deposits and didn’t want to enslave part of their own population to have the necessary manpower. If everyone in a country is living like a King, then, it’s obvious there are hidden slaves.

          • Sorry if I expressed myself badly, I meant to agree with you and my question was sarcasm not directed towards you but anybody who thinks that Europe is 100 % self made. Sure their knowledge comes from themselves (building upon collective human knowledge, including the one of the Muslims) but ressources must come from somewhere. So I agree with you.

      • The UD helped Israel butcher 4009 civilians in Beirut (1982)
        Bin Laden went there and he saw how they had blownmup.tiwers, and he decided to get revenge in it Nd.

        Meanwhile the US wanted an excuse to strengthen their defense industry and destroy Iraq. So they began secretly helpingterrorists (the terrorists didn’t know).

        For example an FBI agent helped in the 1993 WTC bombing. its not even s conspiracy theory, just look at Wkipedia

        • Meanwhile bin Laden was plotting to hijack planes and crash them into towers to repeat the Beirut scenes.

          The US government received multiple warnings, but under the aforementioned scheme, they not only looked the other way, but possibly aided the hijackers get through immigration.

          Essentially a double-conspiracy.

          • PS: The Taliban maintains that bin Laden did not do 911 or rather they still demand proof as they did 20 years back.

    5. Even if Islam was Arab colonialism, there is colonialism disguised as “bringing civilization” like the West does, that results in millions of deaths, countries destroyed, culture erased, mass starvation
      And then there is Islamically shaped Arab colonialism, which creates Empires where every nation benefits, protects lives, infrastructure, cultural differences that don’t oppose Islam (which, if they do, actually are detrimental to humans, like shirk or eating dung)
      India needs Arab colonialism

    6. I also want to ask that there claims Wikipedia other people Muslims Kia 80 million Indians in the 800 years they ruled India I want to ask how much of those were civilians or military people and is the 80 million claim correct can somebody have an answer I see pajeets labeling the worse h0l0causy worse than the one that happened in WWII which even if we accept that it’s not the British genocide of the subcontinent for 200 years takes that title .

      • I remember what you are saying.This is actually based on works of KS Lal.But truth is very much different.Genoecide and massacre,did took place but not in huge number as he mentioned. No wonder even konrad ellst rejected this thesis.SoAS also found his work GIGO.Also,author of history of civilization,also claimed similar things but he neither provides works nor statistics.Rather modern studies actually shows population of India,actually increased during muslim rule.

            • Also we’re most of the victims soldiers or civilians and did Muslims pay reparations for it if a genocide did take place

            • Don’t remember much.Hindu nationalist has activity to make such hype.As I told you k.S Lal has been criticised and a statistics has been by SOAS historian and found garbage in garbage out.Irfan Habib,one of India’s leading historian already rejected his work.And also, konrad ellst, a hindu historian and he himself is pro hindutva rejected K.S Lal work. K.S Lal even made foolish claimed that he proved Mahabharata as historical.At the end,I say don’t take hindu nationalist seriously.

            • Only genoecide I remember was Akbar who killed Rajputs in Chittorgarh,but they were warriors and were in combats.women and children were never been harmed.Also hindu and sikh rulers also killed many muslims both civilians and women.

    7. What a garbage article from a garbage author, while I agree that Islam isn’t just Arab colonialism bani Umayyah and others were DEFINITELY racist towards non Arabs and I’m saying this as an Arab myself

      • What the hell you are saying.And don’t call yourself arab O rafidah.And bani umayyah did have racist tendencies no doubt.But these does not mean,whole Banu ummayah is racist.Abdullah ibn Umar (ra) was a generous,simple and respectful leaders.And also as if byzantines and sassanids were not racist.Chosroe Parvez and yazdegard hated islam and Prophet muhammed because they consider it arab thing.

    LEAVE A REPLY

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here

    Newsletter

    If MuslimSkeptic gets banned from ALL social media, we'll need your email to stay in touch. Sign up NOW!

    Next Steps: Sync an Email Add-On

    To get the most out of your form, we suggest that you sync this form with an email add-on. To learn more about your email add-on options, visit the following page (https://www.gravityforms.com/the-8-best-email-plugins-for-wordpress-in-2020/). Important: Delete this tip before you publish the form.
    Name(Required)

    spot_img

    Popular

    More like this
    Related

    End of US Military Aid to Israel: Victory or Strategic Reconfiguration?

    On November 3, 2026, Donald Trump announced that the...

    A Critique of the Shi’ah Imamate Doctrine

    Our dear brother Daniel Haqiqatjou recently participated in a...

    Manufacturing the Liberal Man: An Epigenetic Theory of Modernity

    A few years ago, I had written an article...