Into the Wild (2007) was a pretty popular movie when I was in my preteen years. It was based on the true story of Chris McCandless. He was born into a typical WASP family. However, after graduation, he felt a sort of existential void. Following his readings, mainly Henry David Thoreau’s Walden (1854), he goes on to become an adventurer (some would describe it as more of living like a tramp), hiking across North America and eventually meeting his death because he was unable to sustain such a fragile existence.
Similar to what is found in Walden, McCandless was seeking a more nature-based lifestyle, away from the urban civilization and its perceived ills, such as the artificial individual and imperative materialism. Many other authors have encapsulated such an approach, with either more or less radicalism, including Jack London and “the Unabomber.” Of the novels I have read, the best to make a case for a rural existence over an urban life are probably John Cowper Powys’ Wolf Soldent (1929) and Ernst von Solomon’s The City (1932).
This kind of “return to nature” philosophy also has a religious derivation. For example, Rod Dreher, an American Christian-Orthodox theologian, popularized his idea of “Benedict Option” in a book of the same title, basically asking American Christians to mimic the ways of these monks who, in order to shield their faith from the turbulences accompanying the end of the Roman Empire, retreated into their monasteries. Dreher asks Christians in the West to do likewise in an increasingly secular environment which threatens their religion.
From the Christian perspective, the best theological treatment of the question of how urbanization and secularization are interrelated phenomena is perhaps Harvey Cox’s book, The Secular City (1965).
Of course, within an Islamic context, we have the concept of Hijrah, patterned after the migration of our beloved Prophet ﷺ to Madinah Munawwarah. In essence, it is the idea that, in order to safeguard your faith (and that of your family) you should perhaps leave your home—which may even be your place of birth—and move elsewhere.
RELATED: Should Muslims Migrate? To Where?
Most readers have probably already come across some of the arguments from both the Qur’an and the Sunnah, so I’ll avoid delving into the technicalities here.
What I wish to look into is a form of “internalized secularism” found in many of these discourses: ultimately, the idea that the urban civilization is something that belongs to liberal secularists.
Indeed, in many of the idealized destinations, you find some sort of pre-industrial world: the mountains, the extended family, the cattle, etc. This is a way of saying that we should abandon the political institutions and the economic infrastructure and leave them to the liberals, while the religious folk will be voluntary self-exiled. In fact, the very idea of the religious folk being far removed from the centers of power is itself a secular ideal.
It’s as though some of these religious individuals have accepted the liberal secularist notion that they have no place at all in the “modern world” and, thus, escape off to a parodied “premodern” world, effectively leaving behind all the things that shape a nation (politics, economics, and even culture through schooling and education) to the liberals.
RELATED: Hijrah to the West: Where Do You Want to Die?
There’s often some criticism leveled against those who want to make Hijrah to places such as Türkiye and Malaysia, the argument being that they seek to move from a liberal secular country to another country that’s liberal conservative (in the sense that it isn’t quite a fully Islamic nation), but I think those choosing the “into the wild” option are far less legitimate. At least with Türkiye and Malaysia (or some Gulf countries, etc.) there’s the sense that Islam can be a force in the modern urban world. There isn’t this tacit acceptance of Islam being unable to have any real reach there, and thus retreating like a monk into an environment of rurality (and often illiteracy and poverty) is the only viable option.
Even if someone were to argue that the urbanized cities of the contemporary Ummah are not ideal (what exactly is the ideal?), there is at least some form of standing your ground and fighting back. For example, their children may go through the top educational institutions of the country (while, of course, maintaining their own identity through religious and Islamic cultural education) and become a counter-weight to the liberal secularists, perhaps even giving them da’wah to Islam and out of the darkness of the liberal secularism they have been consumed by.
Just to make it very clear, this article is in no way opposed to the immensely noble idea of Hijrah for the sake of Islam (obviously). It is merely an invitation for us to reflect seriously upon how some certain specific approaches to it can be a form of internalized secularism.
RELATED: France Reacts to French Muslims Exploring the Idea of Mass Migration


May Allah bless those who understand tawassul and curse those who make takfir
Weren’t you the one accused of takfir in the guarding the gaze article?
No I condemned someone else for making takfir
Tawassul is not praying to dead graves but praying to Allah to forgive the dead not pray to the dead which is what you Shias do May Allah curse you and your ilk who always cry about takfir and yet in closed doors y’all are the biggest takfiris.
The rawafid do takfir of sahaba and are deserving of Allah’s la’anah.
Yes they do
Here you are doing taqqyia you are a kafir your shirk and cursing and hatred do the Sahaba is enough to takfir you
No there isn’t a difference of a opinion of the Sahaba all of them are praised worthy and whatever sins they have done they repented of , you are nothing compared to the dirt underneath Muawiah abu sufyan and hind and amr al as ra is not worth
Dua to other than Allah is shirk and makes someone a kaafir
وَقَالَ رَبُّكُمُ ٱدْعُونِىٓ أَسْتَجِبْ لَكُمْ ۚ إِنَّ ٱلَّذِينَ يَسْتَكْبِرُونَ عَنْ عِبَادَتِى سَيَدْخُلُونَ جَهَنَّمَ دَاخِرِينَ
Your Lord has proclaimed, “Call upon Me, I will respond to you. Surely those who are too proud to worship Me will enter Hell, fully humbled.
Allah hears and sees you, and instead of humbling yourself and calling upon him, you go to a dead guy grave, who doesn’t know you, doesn’t hear you ?
Either you are too arrogant to worship Allah
Or you think that you dua has more chances to be accepted
In the second case, if Allah is angered with you and wants you to repent before accepting your dua, then even if your dua somehow goes through somebody else, Allah will still not accept it
Also since the guy is dead in the grave, by calling him from the unseen you hope and fear him in a way that only Allah deserves
Not to mention it leads to more shirk with time
This rafidhi was spotted many times since 2023. Why are the moderators leaving this rafidhi alone who is trolling offently the comment space ? Wayne and him should be banned.
Some Sufis and barelvis also do grave worship not only rafidhis
This ugly rafidhi has totally deviated the whole topic by his comments. Could moderators delete all the comments that are off topic ? i have some things to say about the relation between secularism and hijra but I won’t say anything before all our off topic comments will be deleted.
This rafidhi troll hijacked the whole conversation to promote his filthy religion where humans are worshipped beside Allah, and the moderation did nothing. Serious question : did shia agents infiltrate “The Muslim Skeptic” ?
It is a stated policy of World Economic Forum to push more people towards the cities. The commentary of Omar Baloch on the mention of destruction of all towns/cities in the Qur’an is also worth considering. I don’t think any place will be safe but I guess its better to die in countrysides than in cities, which are hubs of sinful activities.
Your comment is the only one dealing with the issue, and it is in the last position where it may be not seen. “The muslim skeptic” has à rafidi troll within. In a french speaking islamic forum, we also had rafidhi moderators that reshaped topics, even suspending sunni accounts. It was well known. This forum died partly because moderators let trolls trolling.
It really depends on the country
Why should we fight the losing battle against secularism in the West?