What follows is an enlightening discussion that took place with Ustādh Daniel Haqiqatjou. I personally found it to be highly beneficial, due to which I have decided to reproduce it here so that others, too, may benefit, in shā’ Allāh.
Questioner:
Assalāmu ‘alaykum Ustādh.
I’ve barely even scratched the surface when it comes to this topic, but do you believe there is a compelling argument for the Final Messenger, Prophet Muḥammad ﷺ, being prophesied in the Bible?
In your opinion, does the evidence present a strong and convincing case which can be presented to Christians who may be curious about or receptive to Islām?
Ustādh Daniel Haqiqatjou:
Wa ‘alaykumussalām.
“And, behold! Jesus, son of Mary, said: 0 Children of Israel! I am, indeed, the messenger of Allāh [sent] to you, as a confirmation of [the truth] that has preceded me [in the law] of the Torah, and [as] a bearer of glad tidings of a messenger to come after me, whose name shall be Aḥmad. Then when he came to them with clear [and miraculous] proofs [confirming his truth], they said: This is manifest sorcery!”
This verse of the Qur’ān (61:6) refers to Prophet ‘Īsā (peace be upon him) informing Banū Isrā’īl of the coming of the Prophet ﷺ. Where exactly these words have been documented in their scriptures, is something that is subject to debate. It’s possible that this line of argument may be effective. I, however, don’t have any personal experience with it.
Questioner:

(In reference to the above slide used in the debate with Jay Dyer)
You seem to argue that the Bible offers contradictory accounts regarding whether or not Christ claims divinity. Every other dā’ī I’ve come across tends to build their case by opposing the notion that Jesus makes any direct claim to divinity. They highlight verses which conflict with the divinity of Jesus, characterising them as being clear and unambiguous, while those that apparently support it are deemed to be either fabricated or ambiguous.
Ustādh Daniel Haqiqatjou:
Personally, I don’t believe that this is a consistent position for Muslims to argue.
How can you believe that the bible has both:
- been corrupted; and
- preserves tawhid?
It would seem that these two points undercut each other. It is more consistent to believe that the bible has been corrupted, including in its conception of the oneness of God.
And this corruption is very clear when you study the history of the Bible and compare manuscripts where clear editing has evidently taken place. Early Christians edits of scripture like the Johannine comma only support this further.
Unfortunately, some of the du’āt seem to be completely ignorant in relation to this information, which is why they make arguments like “the Old Testament is monotheistic, so the Trinity in the New Testament is a completely new thing.”
The approach of Brother Jake [i.e., “The Muslim Metaphysician”], on the other hand, is rock solid. He says that he doesn’t care if the Bible were to say “God is the Trinity” on every single page. The concept itself is inherently incoherent, so it doesn’t matter what the Bible says.
RELATED: The Evolution of the Trinity Doctrine in Christian Theology
Questioner:
I’m not sure they’re arguing the second point at all. There are clearly contradictory statements within the Bible. Some passages affirm monotheism, while others allow for henotheistic polytheism. What they seem to be asserting is that the Jesus in the Bible does not claim divinity for himself.
What I find intriguing about this line of argumentation (though I remain unsure of its rigor) is that, if accurate, it would demonstrate a schism between the teachings of the church and the scripture. I tend to lean towards the perspective that there is no clear conception of a Trinity in either the Old Testament or the New Testament. It seems like an ad hoc interpretation.
Ustādh Daniel Haqiqatjou:
Isn’t the implication of arguing that Jesus has not claimed divinity for himself that the Bible depicts Jesus as believing in one God, i.e., tawḥīd?
Questioner:
Yes, they would argue that Christ himself is teaching tawḥīd. When you mentioned the Bible, I was thinking more along the lines that, since Christians affirm the Old Testament—which contains monotheistic, polytheistic, and even pantheistic passages—, it is possible to believe that Christ taught monotheism in the Bible but that the Bible as a whole still contains elements of polytheism.
Ustādh Daniel Haqiqatjou:
(Referring to the biblical verses listed in the above image—John 10:30 “I and the Father are one,” John 10:38 “Understand that the Father is in me, and I in the Father,” and John 14:9 “Whoever has seen me has seen the Father”:)
Do you think these verses are consistent with monotheism? My point was that they can be interpreted in multiple ways. For someone to claim that, no, “I and the father are one” actually means I am a messenger of God AND that is the only possible interpretation… Well, I think that’s a bit of a stretch.
Questioner:
The argument I’ve heard for this is as follows:
If we take “I and the Father are one” (John 10:30) to mean Jesus and God are of one being, then, in John 17:22, when Jesus prays for the disciples that “they may be one as we are one,” using the same Greek word, “hen,” it implies that he is praying for the disciples to become one being.
Since “hen” means “one” in both instances, it is therefore inconsistent for someone to claim that Jesus means “one in purpose” for the disciples but “one in being for himself and God.”
Ustādh Daniel Haqiqatjou:
If you watch my debates, there is a consistent pattern in that I don’t like arguments which live or die on the basis of textual interpretation. These are the weakest arguments that can be made, whatever the context.
I don’t want a Christian, Jew, or Hindu being able to say, well, Daniel’s argument is bunk because he is twisting our texts. I don’t want a Muslim reformer, like Jafed for example, to say it either.
I always bring a secondary independent evidence for whatever I am arguing so as not to rely only on scripture.
And this is consistent with what I believe about the Qur’ān. The Qur’ān is far more clear and unambiguous than the religious texts of other religions, but, even then, we should anchor ourselves in the sunnah (prophetic example) and understanding of the salaf (pious predecessors) and the ‘ulamā’ (Muslim scholars) through time in order to properly understand the Qur’ān.
RELATED: The ‘Ulamā’ Are Like the Stars
Questioner:
This indeed clarifies things in my mind. Shukran Ustādh.
Ustādh Daniel Haqiqatjou:
Limiting your arguments to the contradictions within scripture or the contradictions between scripture and Christian theology are limited in another way. Most Christians interpret the Bible as mostly metaphor. They view the Bible as a human product that is mainly metaphor. So when you want to show that two parts of the Bible contradict each other, it is hard to prove that a metaphor is contradictory to another metaphor. So this type of “contradictions” in the Bible approach only causes problems for a biblical liberalist—and a relatively simplistic one at that.
Questioner:
So, Ustādh, considering all that we’ve discussed here, I believe that, returning to my initial question, attempting to argue for the Final Messenger, Prophet Muḥammad ﷺ being prophesied in the Bible would be a weak strategy. It would likely devolve into a back-and-forth interpretation of verses, with our Christian counterparts ultimately accusing us of misrepresenting their scriptures.
We’d essentially be playing on their preferred field of engagement. I don’t see how we could introduce a secondary, independent source.
Ustādh Daniel Haqiqatjou:
I agree. There may be manuscripts in the future that are discovered which could make the argument less vulnerable to Christian rebuttal. However, short of that being the case, I don’t think endlessly arguing hermeneutics is the best line of attack.
Questioner:
That makes perfect sense.
Ustādh Daniel Haqiqatjou:
The two arguments I find to be far stronger against Christianity, which they simply cannot refute, are:
- The Trinity is a logical contradiction, and Christians throughout history have not been able to agree on what it actually means.
- Because the Bible has not been preserved and is contradictory, Christianity has relied on ongoing revelation via church councils, which has in turn led to doctrine that evolves in response to political pressures.
You’re in a much stronger position arguing along the above two lines rather than going back and forth with Christian scholars on what is the exclusively correct interpretation of this or that verse. The other added benefit, of course, is that these two arguments are thoroughly backed by secular academia, so you can cite independent authorities.
RELATED: Latest Bible Update: Pope Francis Says Homosexuality Is Perfectly Fine


One similarity I notice between Christians and J**s is that Christians believe J**s k*lled God, and J**s believe they can win arguments with God, and are better than God, in other words, both believe that J**s are over God and both believe that J**s humiliate God.
Ma Sha Allah, wonderful conversation. I’m glad you brothers and sisters disagree with and refute common arguments of good-intending Muslims when necessary. Keep it up!
I agree with Daniel I used to use these arguments of the monotheistic verses but hearing Daniel and brother ijaz the trini’s arguments I learned I don’t need to . We can easily disprove Jesus wasn’t god. As the Bible is very contradictory and has verses of monotheism and polytheism . Not only that the authors of the Bible are unknown and wasn’t even written by Essa as disciples but some Greek writes 70 years after he left and years after his disciples past away .
Not only that the fact the Bible can be edited it out and they fact that archeology shows that the oldest bible is the size of a credit card and is traced back to the 1000s 10 centuries after Essa as was saved . And no evidence that the disciples of Essa as believed in Essa as was divine or a god.
If anything Christians can’t decide if Jesus was god or not due to their contradictory verses . So they blind follow their priests and corrupt church fathers .
but the New Testament is ignorant of 70AD and the crushing defeat of Judaism…this event is major bragging points for the early church …but Paul and Peter are still alive at the end of Acts. Acts is post Luke and Luke is considered by all as the last of the four gospels…so Paul and Peter are alive and the Jerusalem temple is still standing? And the early Christians were definitely NOT shy about martyrdom…so the whole NT is complete by 70 AD
John is the last, not Luke. But everything else where adds up.
Can I translate these articles to Turkish in any way?
Ustadh, I request you to include in one of your Haqiqat Show episodes the following topic:
The journey of Christian beliefs.
Elaboration: Christian beliefs about homosexuality, Jews, women’s clothes, women’s education, and many other topics have travelled from the North Pole to the South Pole and seem to be packing their bags to travel back to the North Pole again. It might be useful to have this journey captured in a coherent presentation as well as an article.
It might also be useful to contrast it with the consistency of Islamic beliefs through the ages.