Book review: Post-Modernity, Paganism, and Islam by Jalalul Haq (Minerva Press, 1999)
There is a certain narrative that exists within the Islamic community which asserts that we should try and avoid discussing philosophical issues.
The underlying rationale behind this assertion is one that is not without merit. The argument is that pseudo-philosophical complexities can end up having a negative influence on one’s faith (iman) and can generally lead in many matters more often to confusion than certainty.
Yet, the reality that we find ourselves in today is that we simply cannot escape the dominant trends of Western philosophy. These debates have a habit of inserting themselves directly into our lives through things like globalization and social media. They also have a direct impact on social issues. The most dominant among these ideologies right now is that of Postmodernism, which does indeed shape societal trends, as it has nurtured some of the most radical trends of Feminism (e.g., Judith Butler’s critical engagement with Postmodernism to introduce a transformative perception of the notion of “gender”).
Thus, within the Islamic tradition, many thinkers have tried to take a critical look at Postmodernism. The most popular among them is perhaps Ziauddin Sardar, who argues that Postmodernism is merely a new form of Modernism, including its Orientalist and Eurocentric attributes. Akbar S. Ahmed’s analysis is less damning as, though he deems Postmodernism to be limited, he still believes that it contains some positive elements.
The book that I’ll be focusing on here, however, is Post-Modernity, Paganism, and Islam by Jalalul Haq (Minerva Press, 1999).
While Sardar has been featured in the British mass media (both in the press and on television) and Ahmed has been recognized as a respected academic in the United States (as well as his native country of Pakistan), there isn’t much information available regarding Haq on the internet in terms of biographical data, apart from the fact that he taught Philosophy at the Aligarh Muslim University of India.
Some of the other books that he has authored include Nation and Nation-Worship in India (1992) and Power, Sexuality and the Gods: Studies in Philosophical Paganism (1994).
What immediately differentiates his book on the topic of Postmodernism from those of both Sardar and Ahmed—and is noticeable even from a simple glance—is its sheer size. While the books of the latter are around 200 pages (or less) in length, Haq’s is almost 500 pages long.
But it’s more than just a matter of quantity, it’s about quality too. Haq has evident mastery of the entire Western philosophical tradition. He touches not only upon those that have been involved with Postmodernism directly (such as Foucault, Derrida, Deleuze, and Baudrillard) and indirectly (such as Nietzsche and Heidegger) but even ancient Greek philosophers (like Plato) and Modernist European thinkers (like Kant).
RELATED: Modernism and Postmodernism: What Are They and How Do They Differ?
The book consists of six chapters in total, each of which are roughly around 70–80 pages long.
The second chapter is about how “reason” as an instrumental tool has been demoted in the Postmodern West despite being one of the main weapons of Modernist Europe. The fourth chapter is about the “death of man” despite “humanism” still being a motto of the West, especially when it wants to launch wars in the Islamic world. The sixth and final chapter is titled “Greekjew,” and it is on how Postmodernism entertains a largely underacknowledged link with Jewish thought, particularly Jewish mysticism.
As I often like to do with my book reviews, I will simply allow the book to speak for itself. I have included below some selected quotes so you can get an idea as to the author’s views on various core issues and also get a taste of his writing style.
Please bear in mind that the book goes much deeper into all of the respective subjects touched upon here, getting “technical” but never “too complex.” As such, these brief excerpts are not representative of the very detailed and lengthy discussions, spanning many pages, that are dedicated to each of these individual issues.
Postmodernism as a Religion
Post-modernism is the new religion of the West. As a philosophical articulation of contemporary cultural experience, it is in the process of fast becoming the dominant ethos of our time – in fact, the spirit of our age. From being initially, in its more academic aspects, a new and radicalised way of critiquing literary and philosophical texts, it has come to be seen to represent a whole new perspective on man’s life and the world, and is even considered as a decisive rupture in the cultural history of West. (p. v)
The Modern Self as a Liberal Self
The modern self, for sure, was a revolutionary self. It had its birth in the great French Revolution, the preparation for which was made by the philosophes of the eighteenth century; and it has had since then many duplications and imitations in other places, including the ones in the twentieth century under the name of Marxism. Marxism, contrary to the popular perception, was not an inversion but a retention of modernity, as what it had achieved through all its convulsions was to reiterate and reinforce the talk of revolution. Marxism was, moreover, an ideology of liberation and being as such it was again nothing but a repetition of the idea] which was espoused by the revolutionaries of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. The common aim of all modern revolutions was to effect the liberation of self, and to constitute a liberated or liberal self. (p.12)
RELATED: [Book Review] Rejecting Freedom and Progress: The Islamic Case Against Capitalism
Postmodernism as Paganism
The transcendence of humanity opens up the double possibility of being superhuman and subhuman at the same time, of being god and animal in the same moment. What a saint attempted through his ascetic exercises, through his transgressions of social norms and rules and through his resultant ecstatic raptures, was a mode of being which was above the level of humanity and which ultimately led to his being ranked as equal of the gods, to be a god as such. It is necessary to realise that the gods, as believed in by ‘pagans’ were either the hypostases (i.e. excesses) of the different forces of human nature like knowledge, power, sex or wealth; or, and this comes to mean the same thing, the deficiencies of the complete human nature.
[…]
Our post-modernist philosophers, in self-avowedly following this logic of excess and deficit, can be described without prejudice to their sensibilities as being the philosophers of paganism (or neo-paganism) and their logic also can be called pagan logic. For what makes them pagans par excellence is not some overstretched meaning of the word paganism, but a more direct indulgence in ‘god-talk’, along with all that such talk entails or presumes. (p.22)
Postmodernism and “Unreason”
Post-modernism is the celebration of unreason. It promises to unsettle the ghost of reason, which has taken possession of the animal in man and has oppressed it for so long. The animal in the body, in the trepidations of its feverish dreams, has come to think of being divine, of having a soul, of possessing a reason. In that very same hallucinated state, it turned what was its original act of virtue into an original sin, the resultant shame of which it tries to cover with the fig leaf of reason – which however turns out to be just a fig leaf, barely covering what it tries to hide.
[…]
By rekindling the old enmity between the logos and language, what post-modernism seeks to establish is a counter-culture of unreason and of madness and death. (pp.57–59)
How European Rationalism Was Corrupted Way Before Postmodernism
Modernism and post-modernism have maintained their interrelationship of polar opposition while yet being each other’s support. For the Cartesian reason on which the modernism based itself was not the creative reason which we have just talked about. In its internal structure it was still Platonic, reflective, mathematical and dialectical; though it had also another face which was directed towards the phenomena of the world. With this excess of one-dimensionality, it was natural that it would end up in its own negation. We can see this in the ‘panlogical’ philosophy of Hegel on the one hand and the different voluntaristic, romantic, existentialistic and, finally, the post-modernist irrationalisms on the other hand. Man, the rational animal who ushered in his modernity with the assertion of the supremacy of rationality, has found his fate sealed in the sheer naturality of his animal-existence.
[…]
Hegel’s reason, it may be recalled, was sovereign, authoritative and imperial; and yet as soon as it made its appearance, it found itself surrounded by all kinds of enemies. Fichte and Schopenhauer, Kierkegaard and Dostoevsky, Marx and Feuerbach, and then Husserl and Heidegger, all united to fight their common enemy. But the greatest danger to Hegelianism came not from these ‘others’ who attacked it from outside, but from an enemy who was present within. The dialectic of Aufhebung, as we know it, was a process of thought in which the opposition necessarily gave way to resolution. The end ofthis process naturally was a final resolution, the end of all oppositions and hence all progress. The consciousness at this point became pure and absolute, admitting no other or opposite at all. Since there was no opposition, there was also no dialectic and no logic. The end of logic was the end of logic. ‘Panlogism’ was only the other name of non-logism. We shall see how it was precisely this end of logic, as emerging from the logic itself, that was made to be an argument by Derrida to establish his own anti-logoistic philosophy. (pp.61–62)
RELATED: Is Jordan Peterson a Postmodernist? Only When He’s Asked about God
The Politics of Non-Politics
This deconstruction therefore remains a political act but its politics is so far removed from the normal type of politics (both of‘Left’ and ‘Right’ variety) that the term can easily be taken as being apolitical. There can be any number of issues (imperialism, colonialism, sexual violence, techno-scientific, culture, etc., etc.) on which we must take an oppositional stand; but the opposition should not be done with the self assurance of someone who thinks he possesses the truth or has the panacea for all political ills. The politics of deconstruction does not involve a critique of prevailing political ideologies or a critique of a particular event from the point of view of any of these ideologies; it rather involves not having a point of view at all and yet criticising, rejecting and resisting. (p.178)
From Ethics to Aesthetics
Against the coded, common morality acceptable to all, new ethic is individualistic, creative and libertarian. It may, in fact, more appropriately be called an aesthetic rather an ethic. It is an art or aesthetic of existence, an endeavour for improvising one’s own style of living, a technology of self-creation and self-formation. (p.225)
Postmodernism, Kabbalah, and Feminism
Like the philosophy of Neoplatonism, the Kabbalah explains the creation in terms of ‘spheres’, (the Sefiroth, in Hebrew) which are seven or ten in number, the first one being the sphere of nothing. But unlike the former there is no emanation from this primordial God of nothing, no stretching out of the being of God, but only a turning within, a selfwithdrawal, a ‘crisis’ inside. It is this internal crisis in the being of nothing leading to a kind of self-exile of God from his pure nothingness that creates the world of things. The realm of being is continuous and what breaches this continuity, what creates the gaps and individualities, is the ‘abyss’ (a favourite word, incidentally, of Derrida) or the nothingness that inheres the being. Nothingness breaches the being of God and it is from this breach that the crisis arises and the drama of creation unfolds. A being not so internally breached would have remained in the folded state of its being, without movement and without visibility. The spheres are not the intermediary realities, as all the upheavals of creation take place within the being of God and emerge from the nothing of pure being like the branches of a tree (the tree of God it is called), nothing itself being ‘the root of the root’ of this tree. The most primordial point which manifests the nothing is ‘intelligence’, which is however not a single but a double being called Hokma and the Bina, the masculine and the feminine aspects of God. Nothing itself is sexually undifferentiated but it is what lies behind the difference of masculine and feminine in God. The Bina, the feminine, is indeed the ‘differentiation’ (in other words, the distant precursor of Derrida’s own difference) itself i.e. that which divides between things. It is moreover the ‘supernal mother’ from the womb of which other spheres are born. It is also the subject, the I, of God who originally is neither a subject nor an object. Lastly, it is the Shekhinah, the daughter and the bride of God in whom he casts the ray of his wisdom to fertilise her and enable her thereby to be productive.
One cannot fail to hear in all this the resonances of the feminist ideas that are so characteristic of Derrida and of other post-modernists, though it would be unreasonable to expect a complete correspondence or agreement between the two experiences. The resemblances however go still further. Like, for example, Derrida, who said that the archetypal trace which is sexually neutral has its immediate expression in the feminine principle, in the Kabbalah too it is the Bina or Shekhinah which is said to be the most faithful representative of the Nothing, which occupies the pride of place as against the Hokma, who is somewhat obscure although as male principle its presence is required for the fertilisation of her. (pp.448–450)
RELATED: Sabbatean-Frankism: The Obscure Jewish Sect That Shaped Modernity


There is the one true god. There is man. God gave us rights.
There is human. An invention of the mind. Human is less than man and has no rights only given privileges bestowed by TPTB which can be taken away and is being taken away. That is the NWO.
Philosophy is the tool by which the psychopaths who rule this World persuade us and herd us to voluntarily enter into their next stage of oppression.
It goes much deeper than you know. The 1st Muslim who studied it is the great Al-Ghazzali ” The Incoherence of the Philosophers”. If you look at the progression, M. David Litwa ”
Desiring Divinity: Self-Deification in Early Jewish and Christian Mythmaking” and ”
Becoming Divine: An Introduction to Deification in Western Culture” are highly recommended. From the Egyptians (Hermes Trsmegistos, Thoth) to the Greeks and Romans (Plato, Dionysus, Mithras) to Christianity as defined by Paul – ….