American-Indian Twelver Shi’i democratic socialist Zohran Mamdani, at only 33 years of age, has managed to secure a significant political milestone by winning New York City’s Democratic mayoral primary. He has effectively positioned himself as a key contender for the mayorship of what is America’s most populous metropolis and a global epicenter of its cultural and economic influence.
His ascent reflects a generational shift in urban politics, and it also highlights the growing appeal of “progressive” platforms in major urban centers. This recent news has therefore resulted in an endless barrage of criticisms from the right-wing, who have described his politics as “communist,” while he is a self-described democratic socialist. Other observers have highlighted that his triumph might have been due to his pro-Palestine advocacy.
Zohran’s rise has sparked varied reactions across ideological lines. Segments of the right, both in the West and in India, have expressed discomfort over such a supposedly visible “Muslim identity” being poised to potentially lead one of America’s most iconic cities. Some Muslim voices, on the other hand, have voiced serious concern over his progressive stance on LGBTQ+ issues. In particular, his advocacy for policies such as allocating millions of dollars of public funds towards gender-affirming healthcare has naturally raised questions about alignment with traditional Islamic views on gender and sexuality, though it is possible that this peculiar stance may be rooted in his Twelver Shi’ism.
Beyond the posturing on specific social issues, however, I would like to offer a critique of his political ideology, which I find to be trapped within a secular and materialist paradigm.
RELATED: Dalia Mogahed’s Response to Our MuslimGirl Article: Touting ISPU’s Pro-LGBT Advocacy
The Child of His Parents
Zohran’s political identity is deeply interwoven with his intellectual and diasporic lineage.
His father, Mahmood Mamdani, is a prominent figure in postcolonial studies (a subject that he has taught at the now somewhat controversial Columbia University). He is well-known for his critiques of imperialism and the legacy of colonial statecraft. The Mamdani family traces its roots back to the Gujarati Shi’ah community, a group that is historically characterized by theological marginality (as Shi’ah) and geographic mobility. This mobility, particularly in commerce, enabled many Gujaratis to embed themselves in the Indian Ocean trade networks, with significant settlements in East Africa, including, of course, Uganda, which is where Mahmood Mamdani was born. In 1972, under the nationalist regime of Idi Amin, Uganda expelled its Asian population. This was a move that decimated the national economy. Ironically, however, it also facilitated socioeconomic mobility for many displaced Asians abroad. Armed with education, entrepreneurial skills, and transnational networks, these communities rapidly integrated and often rose to elite status in countries like the UK, Canada, and the United States. This episode, one that is frequently discussed in postcolonial scholarship, illustrates a complex irony: while European former colonial powers often provided refuge and economic opportunity to the expelled Asians, it was “postcolonial” African nationalism that enacted their expulsion. Writers like V. S. Naipaul have explored this contradiction in works such as A Bend in the River (1979).
His mother, Mira Nair—who comes from a Punjabi-Hindu background, Khatri in particular (who, like the Gujarati-Shi’ahs, are a business-oriented and geographically mobile community)—is widely regarded as being one of the most accomplished English-language film directors to have emerged from India. Her body of work consistently weaves together themes of social justice, diasporic identity, and immigrant experience (some aren’t big fans).
Zohran exemplifies the hybrid identity of the postmodern global citizen—an identity shaped by layered histories of displacement, multicultural inheritance, and ideological pluralism. The cross-cultural union between his parents, both communal and personal, reflects this transnational fluidity.
In light of this, Zohran would appear to be less tethered to a singular identity and more representative of the cosmopolitan individual, encapsulating multiple worlds, ideologies, and affiliations without possessing any sort of solid anchoring and perhaps with many contradictions.
In an age that is defined by fluidity rather than fixedness, Zohran is essentially an incarnation of the paradox.
RELATED: Hamza Yusuf vs. Omar Suleiman: The Perils of American Muslim Politics
Can Secularism Defeat Secularism?
Beyond the matter of his personal background, Zohran’s public appeal is, of course, rooted in his political ideology. As a self-identified democratic socialist, he positions himself in direct opposition to the pillars of neoliberal economics (privatization, deregulation, austerity) and public-private partnerships, which he believes erode public accountability. Zohran has consistently challenged corporate influence in politics, critiqued the forces of gentrification that displace working-class communities, and advocated for alternatives to profit-driven healthcare systems.
His platform, which falls broadly into the left-populist spectrum, thus appeals to voters that are seeking structural reform and greater public control over essential services in an increasingly unequal urban economy.
Though he’s often compared superficially to Obama due to a similar “internationalist” family background and notable oratory skills, Zohran is more “radical” or “leftist” than Obama, as Obama remained within the neoliberal framework (he embraced free-market principles and, despite the right-wing protests, his healthcare reform had remained “corporate-friendly”).
But is Zohran radical enough?
From a Marxist or communist perspective, democratic socialism is often viewed not as a revolutionary break from capitalism but, rather, as a reformist compromise, one that ultimately preserves the core tenets of the capitalist system, including private property, market mechanisms, and parliamentary democracy. Critics argue that, by implementing redistributive measures such as universal healthcare, housing guarantees, and welfare protections, democratic socialism may function as a sort of political anesthesia, pacifying the working class, discouraging radical organizing, and encouraging assimilation into bourgeois norms under the guise of economic security and social mobility.
Based on this reading, democratic socialism becomes a mechanism of containment rather than transformation; stabilizing capitalism rather than challenging it.
From the Islamic perspective, we are obviously not calling for implementing the agenda of communism either, as Islam does not call for the abolition of private ownership of the means of production, the end of wage labor, or the establishment of a classless society.
That being said, there remain fundamental tensions between the Islamic worldview and the ideological foundations of democratic socialism. While Islam integrates ethical, spiritual, and communal dimensions into its socio-economic framework, democratic socialism is grounded in materialist philosophy, emphasizing structures of economic redistribution, class struggle, and secular progressivism.
This divergence manifests itself in several ways:
- The compulsory nature of taxation as a tool for wealth redistribution in socialism may conflict with Islam’s emphasis on voluntary charity (sadaqah) and obligatory almsgiving (zakat).
- Socialism’s tendency to frame society through the lens of class antagonism stands in contrast to Islam’s ideal of social cohesion and justice.
- The moral relativism that is often embedded within progressive politics, due to the inherent secular view of “individual autonomy,” can clash with Islam’s commitment to fixed ethical principles that are rooted in Divine revelation.
Regular Muslim Skeptic readers will likely already be quite familiar with this adage, but we always find ourselves returning to it for obvious reasons: secularism cannot defeat secularism. A materialist ideology can’t possibly wrestle against another materialist ideology and emerge victorious. This is because both operate using the same conceptual tools and within similar philosophical landscapes.
Nevertheless, I guess we can still at least enjoy watching Zohran meting out a good old walloping against Netanyahu and Modi!
RELATED: [WATCH] Is Your Zakat Funding the Most Un-Islamic “Islamic” Graduate School? (Bayan Grad School)


How refreshing to finally see some criticism directed to Shiites. I genuinely enjoyed reading this.
I’m confused guys, why is it lthat the religious, “family values” conservative people who this page said are better than liberals being so racist towards him but the evil Liberals have no issues with him being a potential mayor?
Bro, is there a single article on this site where you say “yes I agree somewhat” because it looks like you just come to hate.
No Muslim supports either of the conservative (white Christian supremacist) or the liberal (LGBT peddler and/or atheistic) westerners in totality. Politics is about safeguarding certain interests, that’s all.
The ideology you believe in (post WW2 lefting liberal so called “cultural marxist” ideologies) was literally designed by j–s to subvert and destroy societies.
If we adopt your ideology, we will become destroyed just like how the white countries are being destroyed.
Though, there is one positive effect of this, the j–s depend on this white countries for power, if these white countries they depend on become destroyed due to this, then the j–s won’t have power anymore.
They are destroying the goose that lays the golden egg.
Why do you think that righwing z—ists like Ben Shapiro are against the woke stuff so much? They know it destroys their slave countries that they depend on for power.
Sidenote: His mother Mira Nair is friends with Salman Rushdie.I know we shouldn’t judge her child because of her affiliation with this guy but that is what the right-wingers should consider now to stop their paranoia over him.They should be happy that Zohran’s family is friends with a hardcore kaf*r who hates Islam.
Democratic socialism does not seek to “stabilize capitalism” through welfare programs. That’s social democracy, something entirely different. It aims to abolish it through the electoral process. Zohran even seeks to abolish private property, which goes against Islam’s recognition of property rights. Plus, the left’s support for gender-affirming “care,” civil rights for the LGBTQ+ community, and the like is not rooted in freedom but rather in Marxist critical theory and hatred for the family.