Divided Loyalties: The Western “Counter-Jihad” Agendas of the First World War

    Date:

    Share post:

    Many of us have heard of the infamous “Arab Revolt”: an event in which a number of tribes in the Arabian peninsula sided with the British against the late Ottoman Empire.

    This incident, inflicting a crippling blow on the Ottoman war effort, would contribute to the complete colonization of the Middle East over the following century. An array of other devastating events, including the establishment of the Zionist state in Palestine, occurred as an indirect result of these catastrophic mistakes (to put it generously).

    Although this betrayal was no doubt a significant precursor to the Western domination of the region, a number of other groups within the Muslim world were also actively involved in aiding the British efforts to defeat the Islamic state. This materialized in a series of what can only be considered “counter jihad” proclamations, aiming to de-legitimize the Ottoman fatwa calling for all believers to fight against the British and their allies; and instead affirm loyalty to the very disbelieving powers who had invaded and brutally subjugated the Muslim world.

    It is important to recognize and document the groups and institutions within the Islamic world who had shown allegiance to and supported the Western imperialists in their agenda to destroy the Caliphate, not to suggest that the actions of individuals back then have any necessary bearing over moral judgements about specific groups today but, rather, to point towards the striking parallels in both the identity and actions of their counterparts in our times.

    The Not-So-Arab Revolt

    While discussing the groups which opposed the Shaykh al-Islam’s call for jihad against the European “Entente,” one common misconception comes to surface: was the Arab Revolt really a mass movement based on Arab identity?

    Contrary to the claims of Western orientalists, as well as both Turkish and Arab nationalist historiographers, the vast majority of Arabs both inside and outside the empire remained resoundingly loyal to the Caliph in Istanbul, and they joined the call to struggle against the infidels in droves:

    “…Nor did (the Sharif of Mecca) Hussein represent the wishes of the 8-10 million Arabic-speaking subjects of the Ottoman Empire, most of whom remained loyal to their suzerainty virtually to the end of the war and viewed the desert revolt with total indifference or even hostility … Between 100,000 and 300,000 Arabs fought in the ranks of the Ottoman army during the First World War…”[1]

    The widely taught notion of an “Arab awakening” in the face of Turkish occupation and pan-Islamist ideology was no doubt a myth, with its origins in the agendas of colonial administrators, as even the literate urban population of al-Sham and Iraq never declared in favor of the Sharif’s rebellion. To the contrary, groups such as Palestinian Arabs showed great support for the Ottoman jihad. Richard Meinertzhagen, a colonel in the British army, wrote in his memoirs following the fall of Ramleh (near Jaffa) in 1917:

    “…a large batch of Turkish prisoners were being marched through the village but they were not preceded by their British Guard. The Arabs, thinking that it was the return of the Turkish Army, turned out in force, yelling with delight and waving Turkish flags; it was not till the end of the column appeared and they saw the British soldiers with fixed bayonets that they realized their mistake and great was their confusion. Their faces fell with a bump and they slank disconsolate to their hovels”[2]

    In Iraq, despite the prevalence of sectarian differences, both the urban and tribal populations showed fierce opposition to both the Arab nationalist project and their English backers. The representative of Shi’ah clergy and Marja’a Muhammad Khadhim Yazdi, called upon the Shi’ah population to actively support their Sunni overlords against the disbelievers. When a number of Iraqi prisoners were taken as prisoners by the British army and pressured to support the Arab Revolt:

    “…most of them remained loyal to their Ottoman sultan-caliph…”[3]

    As mentioned in an earlier article, the situation in Yemen mirrored that of Iraq in this regard, with both the Sunni ‘ulama’ and the Zaydi clergy under their Imam Yahya Muhammad Hamid al-Din uniting and scoring a number of victories against the British vassals in the South, culminating in the siege of Aden. Likewise, North Africans under French rule resisted forced conscription and hampered logistics for the Entente, despite not being under direct Ottoman rule for nearly a century. 

    Ultimately, the few thousand rebels drawn to Sharif Husayn’s cause simply represented a very small minority within the greater Arab world. The position of the masses towards the rank of Caliph was presumed to be unquestionable, so much so that much of the population in contemporary Egypt believed that the uprising was in fact a secret Turco-Sharifian plot to deceive the British into giving him their money and resources. It speaks volumes that such a conspiracy would make more sense to them at the time, rather than believing that the custodian of the two holy cities would genuinely side with the infidels against their fellow Muslims.

    RELATED: Fall of Ottomans, Rise of Wahhabis, and the Transformation of Perceptions of Sunni Orthodoxy

    The Colonial “Counter-Jihad”

    There are a plethora of reasons why the British put such an emphasis on agitation in the Arabian peninsula over the course of the 19th century. From an economic perspective, control over the lucrative Bab al-Mandab and Hormuz straits would allow for easy access to the Indian Ocean and their colonies therein. Politically speaking, although most of the region was nominally under Ottoman vassalage, various tribes often acted independently, up to and including raiding their presumed overlord’s Hajj caravans and trade routes whenever it suited them. Much of the population was also made up of rural bedouins who did not have strong social ties with their brothers in the more inhabited parts of the empire.

    All this is to say that British presence in the region on the eve of the first world war was undeniable and that it also had far-reaching potential. Interestingly, according to some sources, the popular sentiment in the Persian Gulf region favored the Ottoman war effort, though various British-backed “shaykhs” gave their hearty congratulations to Sharif Husayn. The Saudi family threw their lot behind the Westerners. Their support for the Sharifian revolt would prove to be relatively provisional, as both Ibn Sa’ud and the British would turn against the Hashemites in the Hijaz once the war was over.

    As established earlier however, it is not accurate to depict the majority of the Arab population as supporting an upheaval against the Caliph, even among the fiercely autonomous Bedouins of the Najd. A significant number of bedouin tribes adhered to the call for jihad and fought against the colonialists and their allies. A notable example of the pro-Ottoman tribes in the Najd region was the Emirate of Jabal Shammar, also known as the Rashidi Emirate, who were based out of the city of Ha’il to the North of Riyadh. The Rashidis and their tribal allies defeated the Saudis in multiple decisive battles from 1915 to 1917 and took hostile actions against the Sharifian rebels, providing much needed relief to the Ottoman garrison defending Madinah. The tides would only begin to turn after Turkish power receded and British material support for the Saudis accelerated by 1918.

    Maximum extent of the Ottoman-loyalist Rashidi Emirate in Najd, late 19th century
    Map of the Arabian peninsula by the end of the war in 1918, showing both the greatly reduced Rashidi Emirate and the ascending Emirate of Najd and Hasa (Saudi State)

    On the other side of the Indian Ocean, conflict was brewing in the lands of Hindustan. The Muslims of India (including modern day Pakistan and Bangladesh) were famed for their relative literacy, institutional advancement, production of high quality human capital, and development of social networks across major cities of the Islamic world. Perhaps due to this unique position, Indian Muslims were especially enthusiastic in the agendas of pan-Islamism and preservation of the Caliphate in the face of colonial occupation, with the “Khilafat Movement” serving as a famous example of this. Even so, much of the ruling elite was ultimately loyal to the British crown. The All-India Muslim League, quick to express their opposition to the Ottomans because of the growing anxieties caused by the fatwa for jihad, issued a resolution:

    “The council of [the] Muslim League gives expression … to the deep-rooted loyalty and sincere devotion of the Mussalmans of India to the British Crown and assures His Excellency [i.e. the viceroy] that the participation of Turkey in the present war does not and cannot affect that loyalty and devotion in the least degree”[4]

    Implicit in this declaration is the claim that the participation of the Ottomans would influence the loyalty of the Muslim population of the Raj. The Nawab of the Bangladeshi city of Dhaka went out of his way to demonstrate his subservience even further:

    “This is not a religious war that it will merit our sympathy. All over India at public meetings the Mussalmans have declared this act of Sultan as extremely silly, and all the leaders have so exhorted their Mussalman brethren that their loyalty (to the British) may stand unshaken”[5]

    This phenomenon of Muslim rulers hastening to announce their loyalty to their colonial overlords in response to the popular sentiment towards the jihad was by no means limited to the subcontinent. In North Africa, the French devoted significant resources to producing media that demonstrated the alleged support from Muslims under French rule against the Turks. Mirroring the language of the Indian Muslim League, the municipal council of Fez in Morocco also issued a telegram:

    “…that the entry of Turkey in the current conflict in no way changes the sentiments of the people of Fez with respect to the motherland [France], for Turkey in entering this war defends no Islamic cause and serves only to assist the barbarity and savagery of Germany…”[6]

    The colonial puppet of Tunis at the time, known as the Bey, likewise called for steadfast allegiance to France and Britain, along with a number of other state-backed muftis. Historian Eugene Rogan, in an analysis of these declarations made by Muslim subjects of the European empires, expresses skepticism to the true motives behind these statements:

    “The language used in these declarations of loyalty adheres so seamlessly to the positions of the imperial powers that it is difficult to believe they are entirely spontaneous … it is reasonable to assume that colonial officials played a part in soliciting these testimonials of support and in editing their contents.”[7]

    In modern times, these kinds of declarations condemning certain traditional Islamic movements or practices have become so commonplace that it would be more remarkable if they were not made. Meanwhile, declaration of jihad by a truly independent, internationally recognized Islamic state would conversely be utterly unprecedented.

    RELATED: Gaza: The Imams Condemn… What Now?

    Spiritual Charlatans of the 19th Century

    The 19th century is a period known for its sudden explosion of spiritual movements and cult leaders. The ideological currents behind these movements show direct continuity with the values of the European enlightenment, including materialism (such as the rejection of miracles), perennialism, egalitarianism, and secularism. Perhaps the most well-known of these modernist religions today is Baha’ism. As an article from Muslim Skeptic summarizes:

    “Bahā’ullāh used his principles of social justice, one humanity, unification of religions, etc., in order to serve his ultimate desire of being recognized as the ‘promised messiah of all religions.’”[8]

    Is it just a coincidence that these very principles mirror the language and agendas of Western colonialists, spearheaded by the British Empire, over the course of the 19th and 20th centuries? If the words of Abdul Baha’ (also known as Abbas Effendi), the leader of the Baha’i religion after his father, have anything to do with it, it seems unlikely. After the fall of Palestine to the British invasion, Abdul Baha’ emphatically proclaimed:

    “O God, the tabernacle of justice has truly been erected on this holy land, and we thank and praise Thee. O God, may Emperor George V, Ruler of Britain, be assisted in his divine achievements, and May his shadow over this realm be everlasting.”[9]

    He was later given a knighthood and the title “Sir” for his support of the empire during the war. 

    Likewise, the Qadiyani cult which came out of British India showed just as much, if not more, allegiance to their fellow disbelievers, with the false prophet Mirza Ghulam Ahmad rejecting the classical Sunni view on miracles, declaring that jihad is no longer permitted, and showing his undying love for his European overlords. On the eve of the first world war and the Ottoman declaration of jihad, the son and spiritual successor of Mirza Ghulam known as Mirza Bashiruddin, made the following astounding claim:

    “The leader of the Ahmadiyya community, (Mirza Bashiruddin) Mahmud Ahmad, wrote that loyalty to the (British) government was a condition of initiation into his sect, and that the founder of the Ahmadis, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, had set out that the Ottoman Sultan held no religious capacity at all.”[10]

    This kind of blood-boiling treachery is a common pattern of modernist movements until today. Another group, in this case the Nizari Isma’ilis, made similar gestures of Western subservience but in a slightly different context. Unlike the other two, the Isma’ilis had a long history preceding the 19th century and were not modernist in their original theology. It just so happens that their leadership, the hereditary line of so-called “Aga Khans,” holds absolute spiritual authority to a degree unprecedented in any mainstream sect of Islam, and it had become what appears to be a loyal puppet of the Western establishment within the British Raj. Commenting on the Caliph’s fatwa of jihad, he also made a number of eye-opening statements:

    “I order all those who follow me to be loyal to King-Emperor”[11]

    “I find that the Turkish Government having joined hands with Germany acting under German orders, is madly attempting to wage a most unprovoked war against such mighty sovereigns as the [British] King-Emperor and the Tsar of Russia”[12]

    It is important to note that, in many cases, the apparent neutrality or silence of various Muslim figures under colonial rule was done out of pragmatic concern rather than true ideological subservience. It would be wrong of us to condemn all of the figures who had avoided conflict or refused to rebel against the colonial regimes in their territories, particularly when the prospect of Ottoman aid was often distant and unrealistic; and suppression of uprisings was done with brutality. Regardless, even though the defense of the last independent bastions of Islam was paramount, the secularizing Turkish nationalists were far more hostile towards the weakened position of sultan-caliph following the Young Turk coup, and they thus had a significant hand in the overall failure of the jihad during the first world war. 

    On the other hand, this does not indicate that those who showed devoted allegiance to the colonial powers occupying the Muslim lands and brainwashing our children had any excuse. The same goes for those who rebelled against the legitimate Caliphate of the time; or aided in its dissolution. Rather, it is these very people who truly betrayed the Muslim ummah and contributed to the dystopian situation the world is in today.

    “Let not the believers take the disbelievers as allies instead of the believers. And whoever [among you] does this has nothing [to hope for] from Allah — except if you are safeguarding against a genuine fear from them. And Allah warns you to beware of Him. For to Allah [alone] is the ultimate destiny.”[13]

    And Allah ﷻ knows best.

    RELATED: Mustafa Kemal Ataturk: The Man Who Tried to Destroy Islam

    Notes

    [1] Efraim Karsh and Inari Karsh, “Myth in the Desert, or Not the Great Arab Revolt,” Middle Eastern Studies 33, no. 2 (1997): 267–312, p. 268 & 290.

    [2] Ibid, p. 292. 

    [3] Ibid, p. 293. 

    [4] Rogan, Eugene. “Rival Jihads: Islam and the Great War in the Middle East, 1914–1918.” Elie Kedourie Memorial Lecture, read 8 July 2014. Journal of the British Academy 4 (2016): 1–20. p. 7.

    [5] Ibid, p. 6.

    [6] Ibid, p. 7.

    [7] Ibid, p. 7.

    [8] Muslim Skeptic Team. “Bahā’ullāh: The Dajjāl False Messiah of Bahā’īsm.” Muslim Skeptic, May 20, 2023. https://muslimskeptic.com/2023/05/20/bahaism-2/.

    [9] Effendi, Abbas. Makatib-i ‘Abdu’l-Bahá [Tablets/Letters of ‘Abdu’l-Bahá]. Vol. 3. p. 347.

    [10] Slight, John. “Reactions to the Ottoman Jihad fatwa in the British Empire, 1914–18.” In The Great War in the Middle East: A Clash of Empires, edited by Robert Johnson and James E. Kitchen. London: Routledge, 2019. p. 8.

    [11] Ibid, p. 8.

    [12] Rogan, “Rival Jihads,” p. 6.

    [13] The Holy Quran. Translated by Ahmad Zaki Hammad, Surah Al ‘Imran 3:28.

    spot_img
    Jabrail Gadgiev
    Jabrail Gadgiev
    Researcher focused on Islamic history and comparative religion

    1 COMMENT

    1. It is always deductive style of writing in regards of this topic. Usual position is pinned then all the ” arguments” are written in favour of the starting idea. Funny thing is , it never deals with situation of the people who did real fighting. I know all of these has nothing to do with the Turks and those few small nations who supported them. Mr Jebrail do these so called brothers realised for example that so called colonialism was much worse for people of Caucasus and Central Asia?
      How about the treachery of Khan Nahichevamsky?
      Let me tell you Arab uprising didn’t bare any strategic problems for the Ottoman Army, don’t overestimate those charlatans from desert.
      Ottoman Army believed in positive outcome till August 1918, only then it became that strategic situation was irreversible. Only Turkish, Caucasian and Balkan units were reliable. Arab units and Kurdish not so much. Ottoman empire had a small population 20 millions, problem of the supply lines, Pozanti tunnel was finished building very late. Ottoman Army fought in Caucasus, Persia,Iraq, Syria,Sinai, Cankkale, Macedonia, Romania, Poland and even few units in the Western front. The war was decided somewhere else, not in deserts. What Muslims did or didn’t do in other parts of the world, didn’t really matter. It was of no consequences. This what I am saying is crystal clear of you really objectively study history from the perspective of the people who fought in that war. I think that writing about sacrifices, steadfastnes, stubbornness,skill and heroic performance of the whole Ottoman Army,Gandarmery, militias and ordinary citizens is much more valuable. After all it was them who fought and died in millions. Afterall it is them who suffered most not some people in India and etc. Afterall, they are the example of the spirit. Afterall it was them that Lloyd George was threatening with the extinction. I believe for once ” brothers” stop crying about themselves. It is pretty clear that these ” tears” are about them. Not about Muslims of Anatolia, Trakiya, Caucasus,Balkans and Central Asia. I think Mr Jebrail as a Caucasian you should know this. Thank you very much

    LEAVE A REPLY

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here

    Newsletter

    If MuslimSkeptic gets banned from ALL social media, we'll need your email to stay in touch. Sign up NOW!

    Next Steps: Sync an Email Add-On

    To get the most out of your form, we suggest that you sync this form with an email add-on. To learn more about your email add-on options, visit the following page (https://www.gravityforms.com/the-8-best-email-plugins-for-wordpress-in-2020/). Important: Delete this tip before you publish the form.
    Name(Required)

    spot_img

    Popular

    More like this
    Related

    A Critique of the Shi’ah Imamate Doctrine

    Our dear brother Daniel Haqiqatjou recently participated in a...

    Manufacturing the Liberal Man: An Epigenetic Theory of Modernity

    A few years ago, I had written an article...

    Daniel Haqiqatjou and Julius Evola… or the Limits of Traditionalism?

    Some of you may have seen brother Daniel Haqiqatjou's...