The Making of Modern Hinduism: Hanuman Chalisa and an “Eternal Religion”

    Date:

    Share post:

    You’d probably have heard by now of the incident that took place aboard flydubai flight FZ1073, which, on September 30, 2026, narrowly escaped catastrophe while travelling from Dubai to Tel Aviv.

    According to the investigation announced by Emirati authorities, the aircraft’s Omani co-pilot, Hamam al-Hammami, attempted to seize control of the Boeing 737 and crash it into Israel’s Ben Gurion Airport.

    Armed with an emergency axe, he attacked the Indian captain, Smit Machchhar, inflicting serious injuries and causing the aircraft to lose thousands of feet of altitude in mere seconds. The captain nevertheless managed to open the cockpit door, allowing the crew and passengers to intervene. Two reserve pilots subsequently brought the aircraft down safely in Saudi Arabia.

    Basically, all the ingredients for a geopolitical blockbuster are present: the fanatical Muslim terrorist, the heroic Indian pilot, and the miraculous salvation of Israeli passengers. It does’t matter that the aircraft was operated by an Emirati airline; or that its passengers were brought to safety via an emergency landing in Saudi Arabia.

    What particularly interests us, however, is something Captain Machchhar revealed subsequent to the incident, during a video conversation with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

    Describing the ordeal, he explained that he had repeatedly recited the Hanuman Chalisa, a devotional hymn dedicated to Hanuman, the monkey-shaped deity of the Hindu pantheon. According to the captain, this was a prayer to which he habitually turned in moments of suffering and distress.

    For the average reader, particularly one who is unfamiliar with Hindu religious history, the reference might appear completely unremarkable. After all, is Hinduism not typically presented as supposedly being the world’s oldest living religion, the “surviving representative of a civilization whose religious traditions stretch back thousands upon thousands of years”?

    Would it not therefore be natural to assume that one of its most popular devotional hymns might possess some similarly immemorial antiquity?

    Well, actually, despite its enormous popularity, the Hanuman Chalisa is not nearly as ancient as such an impression might suggest.

    A Relatively New Hymn

    Hanuman himself is undoubtedly a very old religious figure. He is prominently associated with the Ramayana and the wider devotional traditions surrounding Rama.

    The Hanuman Chalisa, however, is traditionally attributed to Tulsidas, the North Indian poet and religious author who lived approximately between 1532 and 1623. Composed in a vernacular rather than Vedic Sanskrit, the hymn belongs, according to this traditional attribution, not to the ancient Vedic world but to the early modern period. Moreover, its precise textual history is less securely established than one might be led to believe based on its universal attribution to Tulsidas. The antiquity of Hanuman, in other words, should not be confused with the antiquity of this particular hymn, much less with the history of its present-day popularity.

    To appreciate the chronological implications, consider a few comparisons.

    Imam al-Ghazzali (may Allah have mercy on him), who died in 1111, had already produced his monumental theological and spiritual works, more than four centuries before the birth of Tulsidas. The interval separating al-Ghazzali from the traditional period of the Hanuman Chalisa is therefore greater than that separating the American Declaration of Independence from our own time.

    Or consider another comparison, particularly relevant to the contemporary political climate. We frequently hear slogans about how Persians are somehow essentially distinct from Muslims, as though Islam were merely a superficial foreign addition to an otherwise unchanging Persian civilization. Yet the Islamization of Persia began in the seventh century, and Persian-speaking Muslims had already made foundational contributions to Islamic theology, philosophy, literature, and spirituality many centuries before the traditional composition of the Hanuman Chalisa.

    By the time Tulsidas was born, the works of al-Ghazzali and numerous other scholars associated with the Persianate Islamic world had long been part of the intellectual history of Islam.

    Indeed, several of India’s most celebrated surviving mosques – including the Quwwat-ul-Islam Mosque in Delhi, whose construction began in the late twelfth century; and the Adhai Din Ka Jhonpra mosque complex at Ajmer, associated with the same period – predate the traditional composition of the Hanuman Chalisa by several centuries.

    We are thus confronted with the curious spectacle of a religious civilization whose modern representatives frequently emphasize its immeasurable antiquity, while one of its most recognizable devotional compositions is in fact younger than many monuments of the very Islamic civilization that is often portrayed as a comparatively recent “intrusion” into India.

    And the matter does not end with the date of composition. A religious text may exist for centuries without possessing anything resembling its contemporary prominence. As the scholar Philip Lutgendorf demonstrates in his studies of Hanuman devotion, the development of popular Hindu religiosity must also be understood through the expansion of literacy, the circulation of inexpensive devotional publications, and the mass dissemination of standardized texts.

    The modern prominence of the Hanuman Chalisa therefore raises a second historical question, one distinct from that of its authorship: when and through what processes did this particular composition acquire its extraordinary place in everyday Hindu religious life?

    Indeed, a hymn composed in the sixteenth or seventeenth century doesn’t automatically become a universally recognized devotional text in the same century. Between its composition and its contemporary popularity lie generations of religious transmission, institutional patronage, printing, recording, broadcasting, and, more recently, digital circulation. What appears to the contemporary devotee as an uninterrupted inheritance may therefore turn out to be the product of a much more complicated historical development.

    RELATED: The Judeo-Hindu Civilization: A History of Mutual Affinity?

    The Invention of Modern Hinduism

    This leads us to a broader and considerably more consequential question:

    Hindus are very insistent about their religion being recognized as ancient, but how then can it possess so many prominent practices, institutions, and symbols whose present forms are comparatively recent?

    The answer requires us to examine not merely the history of particular Hindu practices but the history of Hinduism itself.

    Obviously, it would be historically absurd to suggest that the British “invented” the Vedas, the worship of Shiva, the cult of Vishnu, or the various Brahmanical and devotional traditions of the Indian subcontinent. Such traditions existed long before European colonialism.

    What is considerably more questionable, however, is the assumption that these heterogeneous traditions always constituted a single, clearly bounded, internally coherent religion corresponding to what is now commonly referred to as Hinduism.

    For much of Indian history, religious identity was articulated through a multitude of overlapping categories: sectarian affiliation, lineage, locality, caste, philosophical school, ritual tradition, and devotion to particular deities. Shaivas, Vaishnavas, Shaktas, Smarta Brahmins, and innumerable regional communities did not necessarily understand themselves as members of a single religious collectivity in the same manner that modern census classifications, nationalist organizations, and public discourse encourage us to imagine.

    The modern consolidation of Hinduism must therefore be situated within the intellectual and political transformations of colonial India.

    British administrators and Orientalist scholars sought to classify the religious traditions of the subcontinent according to familiar categories from European intellectual history. The demands of administration, law, enumeration, and comparative religion encouraged the treatment of highly diverse religious communities as constituent parts of an overarching system called Hinduism.

    In the process, certain Sanskritic texts and Brahmanical interpretations acquired a representative authority that they had not necessarily exercised uniformly over the entire population.

    At the same time, Indian intellectuals and religious reformers were not just passive recipients of European classifications. They participated actively in the reconstruction of their traditions, sometimes adopting European ideas of religion, rationality, historical progress, and national community, while simultaneously presenting their reforms as recoveries of an eternal indigenous wisdom.

    The nineteenth century consequently witnessed the emergence of organizations such as the Brahmo Samaj and the Arya Samaj (the latter founded by Dayananda Saraswati in 1875). These movements did not simply reproduce an unchanged religious inheritance. They sought to distinguish authentic religion from superstition, establish authoritative interpretations of scripture, reorganize religious education, and articulate a more systematic understanding of Hindu identity.

    In Was Hinduism Invented? Britons, Indians, and the Colonial Construction of Religion (2005), the historian Brian K. Pennington examines precisely this interaction between colonial knowledge and Indian religious self-definition.

    His work challenges the simplistic assumption that Hinduism was either an “entirely timeless” entity or an entirely “artificial British fabrication.”

    The more interesting historical reality lies in the transformation of older traditions into a modern religious category possessing new institutional, intellectual, and political significance.

    John Zavos, in his study of the construction of Hindu orthodoxy, makes a related observation concerning Sanatana Dharma (“The Eternal Religion”). Though the expression itself possesses premodern roots, its deployment as the designation of a unified and authoritative Hindu orthodoxy acquired particular force in the modern period. What was represented as eternal religion was, in important respects, being reformulated through the institutions and controversies of modernity.

    It’s hard to miss the obvious irony here: a religious identity declared as timeless was being articulated through precisely those modern processes that supposedly distinguished the modern West from the ancient East (i.e., classification, standardization, rationalization, mass communication, and nationalism).

    This reconstruction was not exclusively theological. It was also political. As nationalism developed, the diversity of the subcontinent increasingly presented a problem for those who wished to imagine India as the expression of a single civilizational personality.

    A common political identity required shared symbols, collective memories, public rituals, and narratives that are able to transcend regional and sectarian differences, and religious traditions offered a powerful reservoir of such material.

    The transformation of Ganesh Chaturthi into a major public festival under the influence of Bal Gangadhar Tilak in the 1890s illustrates the process. Ganesh worship was certainly not invented by Tilak, nor were celebrations of the deity unknown before him.

    What developed was a new public and political organization of the festival, which could mobilize communities through collective religious celebration. An older religious practice was thus invested with new social functions and incorporated into the emerging culture of nationalist mobilization.

    RELATED: Imprisoned by the Self: A Muslim Critique of the Karmic Worldview

    “Mother(-In-Law) India”

    An even more revealing example is the figure of “Bharat Mata,” or Mother India.

    Today, Bharat Mata is frequently represented as a goddess-like embodiment of the Indian nation, often depicted in recognizably Hindu iconographic forms. The figure has become a prominent symbol within sections of Hindu nationalist culture, where reverence for the motherland is sometimes expressed in explicitly religious language.

    Yet Bharat Mata, as a modern national personification, is not an ancient Vedic goddess whose cult has survived unchanged for thousands of years. Her recognizable political and religious identity emerged through the literary, artistic, and nationalist developments of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.

    As Sumathi Ramaswamy demonstrates in The Goddess and the Nation: Mapping Mother India (2010), the sacralization of India’s geographical territory developed through modern forms of representation that drew upon older goddess traditions while investing them with a fundamentally new political meaning.

    Here, perhaps more clearly than anywhere else, we encounter the manufacturing of apparent antiquity: a modern nation is personified through ancient religious imagery, and the resulting symbol is then presented as though it expressed the eternal spiritual identity of the land.

    The consequences for Indian Muslims are hardly insignificant. Within Hindu nationalist discourse, refusal to participate in a religiously charged expression of patriotism can be interpreted as refusal of patriotism itself. We read in an article in The Hindu from 2021:

    Amid the ongoing debate over the chanting of “Bharat Mata ki jai”, Darul-Uloom Deoband, the leading Islamic seminary of the Indian subcontinent, on Friday said Muslims love “Bharat Mata” (Mother India) but they can not worship their “maadre-watan (mother land)”.

     

    In a fatwa issued to Muslims, the seminary said Muslims should not chant “Bharat Mata ki jai” because it is against Islam and “tauheed” (the idea of worshipping one God), which forms the core of Islam.

    The controversy surrounding “Vande Mataram,” which has become a symbol of “freedom resistance” and “national awakening and unity,” provides a particularly instructive example.

    The song, whose title is generally translated as “I Bow to Thee, Mother” was composed by the Bengali writer Bankim Chandra Chattopadhyay in the nineteenth century and subsequently incorporated into his novel Anandamath, published in 1882.

    The novel, set against the background of eighteenth-century Bengal, depicts militant Hindu ascetics engaged in a struggle in which Muslim political power appears as a principal adversary.

    The motherland is represented through imagery associated with Hindu goddesses, while the surrounding narrative places Muslim rule within a story of religious and national recovery. The difficulty for Muslims is therefore not merely a matter of linguistic preference or sentimental discomfort. It concerns the expectation that they should participate in a conception of national belonging expressed through the sacred vocabulary and imagery of a different (false) religion.

    But the point is that a religiously inflected national symbol that emerged in the nineteenth century is presented as the authentic expression of an ancient civilizational identity. Meanwhile, Muslims whose presence in India extends back well over a millennium, for some reason, are told they need to demonstrate their belonging through the acceptance of that comparatively recent symbol.

    The supposed eternity of the symbol thus becomes an instrument for questioning the legitimacy of a community whose historical roots are, in many cases, far older than the symbol itself.

    And so we arrive at a rather amusing paradox:

    The Muslim, whose religion is routinely dismissed as a foreign and comparatively recent intrusion into India, could be offering his prayers in a mosque that is older than some of the most celebrated hymns of his “Hindu compatriots.”

    However, at the same time, this same Muslim is being lectured on his supposedly deficient attachment to an ancient civilization by nationalists that venerate a mother-goddess whose political career had only been launched in the nineteenth century.

    RELATED: An Islamic Critique of the Bhagavad Gita

    spot_img
    Bheria
    Bheria
    Researcher and writer focusing on comparative religion and philosophy

    1 COMMENT

    LEAVE A REPLY

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here

    Newsletter

    If MuslimSkeptic gets banned from ALL social media, we'll need your email to stay in touch. Sign up NOW!

    Next Steps: Sync an Email Add-On

    To get the most out of your form, we suggest that you sync this form with an email add-on. To learn more about your email add-on options, visit the following page (https://www.gravityforms.com/the-8-best-email-plugins-for-wordpress-in-2020/). Important: Delete this tip before you publish the form.
    Name(Required)

    spot_img

    Popular

    More like this
    Related

    Christian Myth Debunked: “The Qur’an Copied the Apocrypha”

    One of the most common accusations raised in modern...

    1967: When Zionism Became Sacred

    There is a recurring debate regarding whether Jews constitute...

    European Hygiene from the Perspective of an 18th-Century Muslim

    The most common historical justification for 18th century colonialism...

    The Hebrew Bible Foretells a Messiah, Not a Divine Man

    As Muslims, we affirm without reservation that Jesus (peace...